Perceptions of Jewish and Israelis in Italy: Evidence from a Survey Experiment on Political Orientation


Abstract


Following the Hamas attacks of October 7, 2023, and the subsequent outbreak of another phase of the Israel-Palestine conflict, the debate on whether criticism of Israel can mask antisemitic prejudice in Western countries has intensified. This study investigates how ideology shapes perceptions of Jews and Israelis in Italy, a context historically marked by right-wing antisemitism and left-wing anti-imperialist critiques. We employ a survey experiment (n=1,119) to measure attitudes toward Jews and Israelis/Israel, to test the pop-theory that posits a "horseshoe" pattern of antisemitism - that is, antisemitic attitudes should be most prevalent at the extremes of the political spectrum and attenuated at more central positions. Contrary to expectations, our findings show no significant convergence of antisemitic attitudes at the ideological extremes. Instead, left-leaning respondents distinguish more clearly between Jews and Israelis, whereas right-leaning respondents conflate the two identities. These results highlight the mechanism that disentangles prejudice from political critique and underscore the moderating effect of ideology in shaping public opinion toward Jewish/Israeli communities.

Keywords: Antisemitism; Political ideology; Survey experiment; Israel; Italy

References


Adalah – The Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel (2018), The basic law: Israel:

The nation-state of the Jewish people, available at:

https://www.adalah.org/uploads/uploads/Final_2_pager_on_the_JNSL_27.11.2018%20.pdf

ADL - Anti-Defamation League (2023) Anti-Zionism as Antisemitism: How Anti-Zionist

Language from the Left and Right Vilifies Jews, available at:

https://www.adl.org/resources/article/anti-zionism-antisemitism-how-anti-zionist-language-left-and-right-vilifies-jews

AJC - American Jewish Committee (2023), 7 Ways Some Anti-Israel Protests Have Spread

Antisemitism. AJC Global Voice, available at:

https://www.ajc.org/news/7-ways-some-anti-israel-protests-have-spread-antisemitism

Anderson B. (1991), Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, London: Verso.

Antoniou G., Moses A. D. (2017), The Holocaust in Greece, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Antoniou G., Dinas E. and Kosmidis S. (2020), “Collective victimhood and social prejudice: A post‐holocaust theory of anti‐Semitism”, Political Psychology, 41(5): 861-886.

Arnold S., Taylor B. (2019), “Antisemitism and the left: Confronting an invisible racism”, Journal of Social Justice, 9(1): 1-33.

Beattie P. (2017), “Anti-Semitism and opposition to Israeli government policies: the roles of prejudice and information”, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 40(15): 2749-2767.

Becker M. J., Troschke H., Bolton M., and Chapelan A. (2024), Decoding Antisemitism: a guide to identifying Antisemitism Online, Springer Nature.

Bell D. (1964), The Radical Right: The New American Right Expanded and Updated, New York: Doubleday.

Bergmann W. (2008), “Anti‐Semitic attitudes in Europe: A comparative perspective”, Journal of Social Issues, 64(2): 343-362.

Bergmann W. (2013), “Antisemitism in Europe today: The phenomena, the conflicts” In Proceedings: Antisemitism in Europe Today: The Phenomena, the Conflicts, Berlin: Jewish Museum Berlin, pp. 1-16.

Beyer H., Krumpal I. (2013), “The communication latency of antisemitic attitudes: An experimental study”, In C. A. Small (ed.), Global antisemitism: A crisis of modernity, Leiden & Boston: Martinus Nijhoff, pp. 83-96.

Bindman G. (2019). “Criticizing Israel is not antisemitism”, European Judaism, 52(1): 111-118.

Binstok N., Gould E. D., and Kaplan T. (2024). “Policies or Prejudices? An Analysis of Antisemitic and Anti-Israel Views on Social Media and Social Surveys”, Journal of the European Economic Association, 22(5): 2329–2373.

Campani G. (2016). “Neo-fascism from the twentieth century to the third millennium: The case of Italy” In G. Lazaridis and G. Campani (eds.), The rise of the far right in Europe: Populist shifts and 'othering', London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 25-54.

Cassata F. (2018), Building the New Man: Eugenics, Racial Science and Genetics in Twentieth-Century Italy, Budapest: Central European University Press.

Chiarini R. (2008), “Anti-Zionism and the Italian extreme right”, Modern Italy, 13(1): 21-35.

Cohen F., Jussim L., Bhasin G., and Salib E. (2011), “The Modern Anti-Semitism Israel Model: An empirical relationship between modern anti-Semitism and opposition to Israel”, Conflict & Communication, 10(1): 1-16.

Cohen F., Jussim L., Harber K. D., and Bhasin G. (2009), “Modern anti-Semitism and anti-Israeli attitudes”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 97(2): 290-306.

Cohen J. E. (2021), “Survey mode, social desirability effects, and antisemitic attitudes: a survey experiment”, Journal of Contemporary Antisemitism, 4(1): 27-36.

Cohen J. E. (2024). “Ideology and attitudes toward Jews in US public opinion: a Reconsideration”, Religions, 15(1), available at: https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/15/1/59

Colombo A. D., Dalla Zuanna G., Quassoli F., Saracino B., and Scioni, M. (2023), Studenti universitari, ebrei e Israele prima e dopo il 7/10/2023: Una rilevazione negli atenei del Nord. Istituto Carlo Cattaneo, available at: https://www.cattaneo.org/studenti-universitari-ebrei-e-israele-prima-e-dopo-il-7-10-2023/

Colombo F. (2022), “Collective Memory and thane Stigmatization of Authoritarian Nostalgia: Evidence from Italy”, SSRN, available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4230213

De Martino C. (2015). “Israel and the Italian Communist Party (1948–2015): From fondness to enmity”, Communist and Post-Communist Studies, 48(4): 281-290.

Lipstadt D. E. (2019), Antisemitism: Here and Now, New York: Schocken.

Faye P. J. (2002), Le siècle des idéologies, Paris: Gallimard.

Fiske S. T., Cuddy A. J. C., Glick P., and Xu, J. (2002), “A model of (often mixed) stereotype content: Competence and warmth respectively follow from perceived status and competition”, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 82(6): 878–902.

GESIS - Leibniz-Institut für Sozialwissenschaften (2018), German General Social Survey – ALLBUS 2016, GESIS Data Archive, Cologne. ZA5252 Data file Version 1.0.0.

Gordon R. S. (2006). “The Holocaust in Italian collective memory: il giorno della memoria, 27 January 2001”, Modern Italy, 11(2): 167-188.

Hersh E., Royden, L. (2023). Antisemitic attitudes across the ideological spectrum. Political Research Quarterly, 76(2): 697-711.

Hirsh D. (2017), Contemporary left antisemitism, London: Routledge.

Hobsbawm E. (2010), Age of revolution: 1789-1848, Hachette UK.

Inbari M., Bumin K. M., and Byrd, M. G. (2021), Why do evangelicals support Israel? Politics and Religion, 14(1): 1-36.

Judaken J. (2008). “So what's new? Rethinking the ‘new antisemitism’ in a global age”, Patterns of Prejudice, 42(4-5): 531-560.

Kantor A. (2022). “An Overview of Contemporary Antisemitism”, INSS Publication, available at: https://www.inss.org.il/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/specialpublication-28012022-2. Pdf

Kaplan E. H., Small C. A. (2006). “Anti-Israel sentiment predicts anti-Semitism in Europe”, Journal of Conflict Resolution, 50(4): 548-561.

Kempf W. (2015), “Anti-Semitism and criticism of Israel: Methodology and results of the ASCI survey”, Conflict and Communication Online, 14(1): 1-20.

Klaff L. (2023), “A new form of the oldest hatred: mapping antisemitism today”, In A. Johnson (ed.) Mapping the New Left Antisemitism, London: Routledge, pp. pp. 13-27.

Klug B. (2003), “The collective Jew: Israel and the new antisemitism”, Patterns of prejudice, 37(2): 117-138.

Klug B. (2005), “Is Europe a lost cause? The European debate on antisemitism and the Middle East conflict”, Patterns of Prejudice, 39(1): 46-59.

Klug B. (2013), “Interrogating ‘new anti-Semitism'”, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 36(3): 84-98.

Klug B. (2014), “Anti-Zionism and Antisemitism: Understanding the Differences”, Journal of Palestine Studies, 43(3): 16–31.

Lipset S.M., Raab E. (1971). The Politics of Unreason: Right-Wing Extremism in America, 1790–1969, London: Heinemann Educational Publishers.

Rigano G. (2009), “Gli ebrei e la destra, la destra e gli ebrei”, Studi storici, 50(1): 85-99.

Roy S. (2010), “Reflections on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in US public discourse: legitimizing dissent”, Journal of Palestine Studies, 39(2): 23-38.

Sarfatti M. (2006), The Jews in Mussolini's Italy: From Equality to Persecution, Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.

Steger M. B. (2008), The rise of the global imaginary: Political ideologies from the French revolution to the global war on terror, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Sunshine S. (2019), “Looking left at antisemitism”, Journal of Social Justice, 9: 1-67.

Tajfel H. (1981), Human Groups and Social Categories: Studies in Social Psychology, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Tibi B. (1997), Arab Nationalism between Islam and the Nation-State, London: Macmillan Press.

Troschke H. (2024), “Disloyalty/Jewish Loyalty”, In Becker M. J., Troschke H., Bolton M., and Chapelan, A. Decoding Antisemitism: A Guide to Identifying Antisemitism Online, Cham: Springer Nature Switzerland, pp. 115-126.

Wlezien C., and Miller A. H. (1997). “Social groups and political judgments”, Social Science Quarterly, 78(3): 625-640.

Young J. E. (1988), The Texture of Memory: Holocaust Memorials and Meaning. Newark: Yale University Press.

Zacher H., and Shemla M. (2024). “Political ideology and attitudes towards Israel in Germany in the aftermath of the 10/7 massacres: A test of horseshoe theory”, Israel Affairs, 29(1): 1–15.

Ziv T. (2022), “I will bless those who bless you”: evangelicalism and support for Israel in Latin America”, Politics and Religion, 15(3): 485-505.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
کاغذ a4 ویزای استارتاپ
Bookmark and Share


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.