The Elephant in the Room. Change and Continuity in Arab Public Opinion on the Palestinian Cause after October 7th


Abstract


Since the founding of the State of Israel in 1947, the Palestinian issue has always been a major concern for people in the Middle East and North Africa, a divisive factor among governments in the area, and a cause of political polarization. However, with the emergence of the Arab Uprisings in 2010-2011 and the consequent sectarianization of regional political alliances, the Palestinian issue seemed to have lost its centrality, with some Arab countries increasingly inclined toward the recognition of the State of Israel and normalization of relations. On October 7, 2023, the Hamas-led attacks and subsequent Israeli retaliation brought the issue back to the center of regional and international debate, provoking outrage among citizens across the region and calling normalization processes back into question, demonstrating that the issue, dismissed at the élite-level, has not lost its relevance for the Arab public. How has Arab public opinion on the Palestinian issue changed in the years since the Arab Uprisings, and how has it changed since the October 7 attacks? Through a longitudinal analysis of the Arab Opinion Index, three interesting elements emerge. First, although in the period between 2011 and 2023 the Palestinian cause continued to be considered a regional and Arab cause rather than a national and Palestinian on by the majority of public opinion, that majority dramatically increased after Israeli retaliation, especially in the countries most likely to normalize relations with Israel. Second, public opinion continues to be overwhelmingly opposed to recognition of the state of Israel, but this figure fell further after October 7, and is particularly steep in countries where approval of recognition of Israel was relatively more widespread. Third, while from 2011 to 2023 Israel was considered the greatest threat to stability and security in the region, after the October 7 retaliation that role is filled by the United States.

Keywords: Public opinion; Palestinian cause; opinion polls; Israel; normalization

References


Abdo G. (2017), The new sectarianism: The Arab uprisings and the rebirth of the Shi'a-Sunni

Divide, Oxford University Press.

Ahmadov R. (2005). “The US Policy toward Middle East in the Post-Cold War

Era”, Alternatives: Turkish Journal of International Relations, 4(1&2): 138-150.

AlMasri M. (2021), “Assessing Arab Public Opinion Toward the Palestinian

Issue”, AlMuntaqa, 4(1): 99-107.

Ardovini L. (2022), “Competing Islams: Religious legitimacy and the foreign policies of Saudi

Arabia and Iran”, In Mabon, S. and E. Wastnidge (eds.), Saudi Arabia and Iran Manchester:

Manchester University Press, pp. 55-73.

Bailey S. D. (2016), Four Arab-Israeli wars and the peace process. NewYork: Springer.

Beck M. (2020), “The aggravated struggle for regional power in the Middle East: American

allies Saudi Arabia and Israel versus Iran”, Global Policy, 11(1): 84-92.

Beckerman G. (2023), “The Middle East Region is Quieter Today Than It Has Been in Two

Decades”. The Atlantic, available at:

https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2023/10/israel-war-middle-east-jake

sullivan/675580/

Benstead L. J. (2019), “Shifting Attitudes in the Arab World Toward Israel: the Importance of

Public Diplomacy”, CPD Perspectives, USC Center on Public Diplomacy.

Buckley N., Marquardt K. L., Reuter O. J. and Tertytchnaya K. (2022), Endogenous

popularity: How perceptions of support affect the popularity of authoritarian regimes. V-Dem

working paper, 132.

Cafiero G. (2024), “Why Arab leaders aren’t helping the Palestinians in Gaza”, Responsible

Statecraft, available at: https://responsiblestatecraft.org/arab-leaders-not-helping-palestinians/

Campanini M. (2014), Storia del Medio oriente contemporaneo, Bologna: Il Mulino.

Chen J. and Xu Y. (2017), “Why do authoritarian regimes allow citizens to voice opinions

publicly?”, The Journal of Politics, 79(3): 792-803.

Clark J. A. (2006), “The conditions of Islamist moderation: Unpacking cross-ideological

cooperation in Jordan”, International journal of Middle East studies, 38(4): 539-560.

Clarke C. P. and Kenney M. (2023). “Hamas Is Not ISIS – and the Comparison itself Is

Counterproductive”, Politico, available at:

https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2023/11/21/hamas-isis-are-not-the-same-00128107.

Daga G. and Simonelli L. (2023), “Saudi Arabia’s Balancing Game: The Palestinian Cause and

Regional Leadership”, IAI Commentaries, 23(57): 1.

Dalacoura K. (2013), “The Arab uprisings two years on: Ideology, sectarianism and the

changing balance of power in the Middle East”, Insight Turkey, 15(1): 75-89.

Darwich M. (2017), “Creating the enemy, constructing the threat: The Diffusion of Repression

Against the Muslim Brotherhood in the Middle East”, Democratization, 24(7): 1289-1306.

Döpfner M. (2023), “The enemies of democracy are testing us”, Politico, available at:

https://www.politico.eu/article/enemies-democracy-test-israel-hamas-russia-ukraine/

Dorsey J.M. (2020), “Ignore at your peril: Palestine ranks high in Arab public opinion”,

Modern Diplomacy, available at: https://moderndiplomacy.eu/2020/08/25/ignore-at-your-

peril-palestine-ranks-high-in-arab-public-opinion/

Elgindy K. (2012), “Egypt, Israel, Palestine”, The Cairo Review of Global Affairs, 25.

Faheema N. (2023), “Shifting Politics Between Muslim States & Israel: From the Khartoum

Declaration to the Abraham Accords”, Muslim Politics Review, 2(2): 163-207.

Gause F. G. (2015), “Revolution and threat perception: Iran and the Middle

East”, International Politics, 52(5): 637-645.

Glasius M. (2018), “What Authoritarianism Is … and Is Not: A Practice

Perspective”, International Affairs, 94(3) : 515–533.

Haklai O. and Rass R. A. (2022), “The fourth phase of Palestinian Arab politics in Israel: The

centripetal turn”, Israel Studies, 27(1): 35-60.

Harlow B. (1986), “Egyptian Intellectuals and the Debate on the" Normalization of Cultural

Relations”, Cultural Critique, 4: 33-58.

Hinnebusch R. (2017), “Revisiting the 1967 Arab-Israel war and its consequences for the

Regional system”, British Journal of Middle eastern studies 44(4): 593-609.

Hoodbhoy P. (2005), “Afghanistan and the genesis of global jihad:, Peace Research, 37(1):

-30.

Karawan I. A. (1994), “Arab Dilemmas in the 1990s: Breaking Taboos and Searching for

Signposts”, Middle East Journal, 48(3): 433-454.

Kedar M. (2020), Why Do Arabs Hate the Palestinians?. BESA – Begin-Sadat Center for

Strategic Studies. BESA Center Perspectives Paper No. 1,758, Bar-Ilan University, available

at: https://besacenter.org/do-arabs-hate-palestinians/

Kerr, M. (1965), The Arab Cold War, 1958-1964. A Study of Ideology in Politics, Oxford:

Oxford University Press.

Khawaja N. U. A. (2013), “Egypt's Foreign Policy Analysis: From Nasser to Morsi”, Pakistan

Horizon, 66(1/2): 43-63.

Kornbluth D. (2002), “Jordan and the Anti-normalization Campaign, 1994-2001”, Terrorism

and Political Violence, 14(3): 80-108

Kumaraswamy P. R. (2009). The Friendship with Israel: India Squares the Circle, Insights

, Middle East Institute, available at: https://mei.nus.edu.sg/wp-

content/uploads/2018/01/MEI-Insights-004.pdf

Mandelbaum M. (2024). “The Wars in Gaza and Ukraine Are the Same War”. Jerusalem

Strategic Tribune, available at: https://jstribune.com/mandelbaum-the-wars-in-gaza-and-

ukraine-are-the-same-war/

Meital Y. (2013), “The October War and Egypt’s Multiple Crossings”, In A. Siniver (ed.), The

Yom Kippur War: Politics, Legacy, Diplomacy, Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 49-66.

Middle East Eye (2024), “Saudi crown prince said he personally “doesn’t care” about

Palestinian issue”, available at: https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/saudi-crown-prince-

personally-doesnt-care-palestine-issue

Molinari M. (2024), La Nuova Guerra contro le Democrazie. Così le autocrazie vogliono

stravolgere l’ordine internazionale. Milano: Rizzoli.

Parkhomchuk O. and Sido A. (2024), “The Islamic Factor in international relations in the

Middle East”, Аctual Problems of International Relations, 1(160): 11-16.

Rabinovich I. (2009), Waging Peace: Israel and the Arabs, 1948-2003-Updated and Revised

Edition, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Rahman O et al. (2024), “Arab Public Opinion Under Pressure”, Akfar – Middle East Council

on Global Affairs, available at: https://mecouncil.org/blog_posts/public-opinion-under-

pressure/

Reuters (2023), “Israel’s new war cabinet vows to wipe Hamas off the earth’”, available at:

https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/netanyahu-gantz-agree-form-emergency-israel-

government-statement-2023-10-11/

Robbins M. (2020), Taking Arabs’ pulse on normalization of ties with Israel, Arab Barometer.

Robbins M. (2021), “Arab Public Feelings about Normalization of Arab Countries with

Israel”, IEMed, Mediterranean Yearbook.

Robbins, M. (2024), “The enemy of my enemy is my friend”. In Rahman, O. et al. (ed.), Arab

Public Opinion Under Pressure, Akfar – Middle East Council on Global Affairs, available at:

https://mecouncil.org/blog_posts/public-opinion-under-pressure/

Robbins M., Jamal A. A. and Tessler M. (2024), “America Is Losing the Arab World: And

China Is Reaping the Benefits”, Foreign Affairs, 103, available at:

https://www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/america-losing-arab-world

Robbins,M. (2025), “MENA Publics and the Future of Normalization with Israel”, Arab

Barometer.

Roll, S. (2024), “Ice age for the'cold peace'between Egypt and Israel: How the Gaza war is

affecting bilateral relations”, SWP Comment, available at: https://www.swp-

berlin.org/publikation/ice-age-for-the-cold-peace-between-egypt-and-israel

Roy O. (2012), “The transformation of the Arab world”, Journal of Democracy, 23(3): 5-18.

Ryan,C. R. (1998), “Peace, bread and riots: Jordan and the International Monetary

Fund”, Middle East Policy, 6(2): 54-66.

Rubin B. (1998), “Israel, the Palestinian Authority, and the Arab States”, MERIA

Journal, 4, available at: https://ciaotest.cc.columbia.edu/olj/meria/meria198_rubin.html

Schwedler J. (2003), “More than a mob: The dynamics of political demonstrations in

Jordan”, Middle East Report, (226): 18-23.

Shlaim A. (2008), Lion of Jordan. London: Vintage.

Shvili J. (2023), “Why Palestinians’ bad behavior has made them pariahs in the Arab world”

Facts & Logic About the Middle East, available at: https://www.factsandlogic.org/why-

palestinians-bad-behavior-has-made-them-pariahs-in-the-arab-world/

Solarz A. M. (2020), “Religion and international relations in the Middle East as a challenge for

International Relations (IR) studies”, Religions, 11(3), 150, available at:

https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/11/3/150

Toameh K.A. (2012), “Why Arabs Hate and Kill Palestinians” Gatestone Institute

International Policy Council, available at:

https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/3515/arabs-hate-kill-palestinians

Valbjørn M. and Bank A. (2012), “The new Arab cold war: Rediscovering the Arab dimension

of Middle East regional politics”, Review of International Studies, 38(1): 3-24.

Valbjørn M., Bank A. and Darwich M. (2024), “Forward to the Past? Regional Repercussions

of the Gaza War”, Middle East Policy, 31(3): 3-17.

Weeks J. L. (2008), “Autocratic audience costs: Regime type and signaling resolve”, International Organiza-tion, 62(1) : 35-64.

Weeks J. L. and Crunkilton, C. (2017), “Domestic constraints on foreign policy in authoritarian systems” In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. Oxord : Oxford University Press.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
کاغذ a4 ویزای استارتاپ
Bookmark and Share


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.