Populist Understandings of the Law: A Conservative Backlash?


Abstract


The main argument is that the contemporary manifestations of right-wing populism in Europe ought to be understood, at least in part, as reactions to a distinctive form of postwar European society, which I will call here embedded constitutional democracy. The argument is that the populist reaction to embedded constitutional democracy generally takes a conservative form. This conservatism is expressed in rather different ways (ranging from ethnoreligious views to 'illiberal liberal' ones), but at the same time populism displays a shared core of criticisms on liberalism, and in particular regarding the internationalized or global version of liberalism. In the article, I will start with a brief analysis of the emergence of postwar society in the form of embedded constitutional democracy, used as a backcloth for the subsequent discussion of critical views of liberal understandings of the law in conservative populist thinking. I will, then, focus on populists' critical views of liberalism and 'globalism', analyzed in the form of contemporary articulations of (conservative) populism in both East-Central Europe (Hungary and Poland), and Western Europe (France, Italy, the Netherlands). In order to identify ideological affinities and critical positions, I discuss four themes: abstractness and inauthenticity, identity threat, domination, and legal fundamentalism.

DOI Code: 10.1285/i20356609v13i3p1433

Keywords: anti-liberalism, conservatism, legal fundamentalism, populism, rule of law

References


AfD (2017), Manifesto for Germany. The Political Programme of the Alternative for Germany.

Almeida, D. (2017), ‘Exclusionary secularism: the Front national and the reinvention of laïcite’, Modern & Contemporary France, 25(3), 249-263.

Baudet, T. (2012), The significance of borders: why representative government and the rule of law require nation states, unpublished

PhD thesis, University of Leiden.

Baudet, T. (2013), Oikofobie, Prometheus.

Baudet, T. (2019), ‘Houellebecq’s Unfinished Critique of Liberal Modernity’, American Affairs, III:2, available at: https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2019/05/houellebecqs-unfinished-critique-of-liberal-modernity/.

Becchi, P. (2019), Manifesto sovranista. Per la liberazione dei popoli europei, Giubilei Regnani.

Blokker, P. (2013), New democracies in crisis?: a comparative constitutional study of the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Romania and Slovakia, London/New York: Routledge.

Blokker, P. (2019), ‘Populism as a constitutional project’, International Journal of Constitutional Law 17/2.

Blokker, P. (2019), ‘Constitutionalism, judicialization, and human rights in the integration of European society’, in: Johann Arnason (ed.), European Integration: Historical Trajectories, Geopolitical Contexts, Edinburgh University Press.

Brubaker, R. (2017), ‘Between nationalism and civilizationism: the European populist moment in comparative perspective’, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 40(8), 1191-1226.

Brunkhorst, H. (2016), ‘Constituent Power and Constitutionalization in Europe’, International Journal of Constitutional Law (14)3, 680–96.

Bugaric, B. (2019), ‘Could populism be good for constitutional democracy?’, Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 15, 41-58.

Bulli, G. (2018), ‘The populist representation of the people in the Italian ius soli political debate’, Fitzi, G., Mackert, J. and Turner, B.S. (eds.) Populism and the Crisis of Democracy: Volume 3: Migration, Gender and Religion, Routledge.

Cliteur, P. (2004), Tegen de decadentie. De democratische rechtstaat in verval, Arbeiderpers.

Cliteur, P. (2018), ‘De democratische rechtstaat en de verdediging van het Westen’, in: F. Bosch (Ed.), Wereld op een keerpunt: waarheen?, Soesterberg: Uitgeverij Aspekt, 289-302.

Croce, M. (2018), The Politics of Juridification, Routledge.

Csillag, T. and I. Szelenyi (2015), ‘Drifting from liberal democracy. Neo-conservative ideology of managed illiberal democratic capitalism in post-communist Europe’, Intersections. East European Journal of Society and Politics, 1(1), Available at: .

Dąbrowska, E. (2018), ‘New conservatism in Poland: The discourse coalition around Law and Justice’, in: K. Bluhm and M. Varga (eds.), New Conservatives in Russia and East Central Europe, Routledge, 92-112.

De la Torre, C. and O. Mazzoleni (2019), ‘Do we need a minimum definition of populism? An appraisal of Mudde’s conceptualization’, Populism 2(1), 79-95.

Eltchaninoff, M. (2017), Inside the Mind of Marine Le Pen, Oxford University Press.

Faber, S. (2018), ‘Is Dutch Bad Boy Thierry Baudet the New Face of the European Alt-Right?’, Nation, 306(13), 20-26.

Ferejohn, J. (2002), ‘Judicializing politics, politicizing law’, Law and contemporary problems, 65(3), 41-68.

Fournier, T. (2019), ‘From rhetoric to action, a constitutional analysis of populism’, German Law Journal, 20(3), 362-381.

Freeden, M. (2008), ‘European liberalisms: An essay in comparative political thought’, European Journal of Political Theory, 7(1), 9-30.

Furedi, F. (2017), Populism and the European Culture Wars: The Conflict of Values Between Hungary and the EU, Routledge.

Gray, J. (1995), Two Faces of Liberalism, Cambridge: Polity.

Grzebalska, W. and A. Pető (2018), ‘The gendered modus operandi of the illiberal transformation in Hungary and Poland’, Women's Studies International Forum 68, 164-172.

Gyorfi, T. (2016), Against the new constitutionalism, Cheltenham, UK/Northampton, MA, USA: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Havlík, V. (2019), ‘Technocratic Populism and Political Illiberalism in Central Europe’, Problems of Post-Communism.

Hirsch Ballin, E. (2011), ‘Henk, Ingrid en de rechtsstaat’, in J. Thomassen et al., Populisme: Verrijking of bedreiging van de democratie?, Koninklijke Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen, 13-19.

Hirschl, R. (2004), ‘The political origins of the new constitutionalism’, Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies, 11(1), 71-108.

Hirschman, A.O. (1991), The rhetoric of reaction, Harvard University Press.

Jasiecki, K. (2018), ‘‘Conservative modernization’ and the rise of Law and Justice in Poland’, in K. Bluhm and M. Varga (eds.), New Conservatives in Russia and East Central Europe, Routledge, 130-153.

Lánczi, A. (2015), Political Realism and Wisdom, Palgrave.

Le Pen, M. (2017), ‘144 engagements présidentiels’, available at: https://www.marine2017.fr/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/projet-presidentiel-marine-le-pen.pdf.

Legutko, R. (2016), The demon in democracy: Totalitarian temptations in free societies, Encounter Books.

Legutko, R. (2008), ‘What's Wrong With Liberalism?’, Modern Age 50(1). https://www.questia.com/magazine/1G1-180569722/what-s-wrong-with-liberalism

Madsen, M. (2019), ‘Resistance to the European Court of Human Rights: The Institutional and Sociological Consequences of Principled Resistance’, forthcoming in: Principled Resistance to ECtHR Judgments-A New Paradigm.

Madsen, M.R. and C. Thornhill (2014), ‘Introduction: Law and the formation of modern Europe - perspectives from the historical sociology of law’, in M.R. Madsen and C. Thornhill (eds), Law and the Formation of Modern Europe: Perspectives from the Historical Sociology of Law, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1-25.

Marks, S. (2013), ‘Four Human Rights Myths’, in David Kinley et al., (eds.), Human Rights: Old Problems, New Possibilities, Cheltenham.

Matyja, R. (2015), ‘Songs of innocence and songs of experience’, in M. Kopeček and P. Wciślik, (eds.), Thinking Through Transition, CEUPress, 201–235.

Moffitt, B. (2017), ‘Liberal illiberalism? The reshaping of the contemporary populist radical right in Northern Europe’ Politics and Governance, 5(4), 112-122.

Moyn, S. (2018), Not enough: Human rights in an unequal world, Harvard University Press.

Müller, J.W. (2011), Contesting democracy: Political ideas in twentieth-century Europe, Yale University Press.

Nash, K. (2016), ‘Politicising human rights in Europe: Challenges to legal constitutionalism from the Left and the Right’, The International Journal of Human Rights, 20(8), 1295-1308.

O’Sullivan, N. (2015), ‘Conservatism’, in: M. Freeden, L.T. Sargent, and M. Stears (eds.), The Oxford handbook of political ideologies, OUP Oxford.

Oklopcic, Z. (2019), ‘Imagined ideologies: Populist figures, liberalist projections, and the horizons of constitutionalism’, German Law Journal 20:2, 201-224.

Oomen, B.M. (2016), ‘A serious case of Strasbourg-bashing? An evaluation of the debates on the legitimacy of the European Court of Human Rights in the Netherlands’, The International Journal of Human Rights, 20(3), 407-425.

Oudenampsen, M. (2018), ‘Een genealogie van Nederlands Nieuw Rechts’, B en M: Tijdschrift voor Beleid, Politiek en Maatschappij, 45(1), 106-110.

Pratt, J. (2020), Law, Insecurity and Risk Control. Neo-liberal Governance and the Populist Revolt, Springer.

Pratt, J. and M. Miao (2019), ‘Risk, Populism and Criminal law’, New Criminal law review 22, 391-433.

Přibáň, J. (2002), Dissidents of Law, Ashgate.

Přibáň, J. and W. Sadurski, ‘The Role of Political Rights in the Democratization of Central and Eastern Europe’, in: W. Sadurski (ed), Political Rights under Stress in 21st Century Europe, Oxford University Press 2006), 196-238.

Reid, S. and M. Le Pen (2016), ‘France’s Next Revolution? A Conversation with Marine Le Pen’, Foreign Affairs, 95(6), 2-8.

Ruggie, J.G. (1982), ‘International regimes, transactions, and change: embedded liberalism in the postwar economic order’, International organization, 36(2), 379-415.

Sajó, A. and R. Uitz (2017), The Constitution of Freedom: An Introduction to Legal Constitutionalism, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Sampson, R. J. and D. Jeglum Bartusch (1998), ‘Legal Cynicism and (Subcultural?) Tolerance of Deviance: The Neighborhood Context of Racial Differences’, Law & Society Review, 32, 777–804.

Scheppele, K.L. (2017), ‘The Social Lives of Constitutions’, in P. Blokker and C. Thornhill (eds), Sociological Constitutionalism, Cambridge University Press, 35-66.

Scheppele, K.L. (2019), ‘The opportunism of populists and the defense of constitutional liberalism’, German Law Journal, 20(3), 314-331.

Schwörer, J. (2018), ‘Right-wing populist parties as defender of Christianity? The case of the Italian Northern League’, Zeitschrift für Religion, Gesellschaft und Politik, 2(2), pp. 387-413.

Sledzinska-Simon, A. (2017), ‘The Polish Revolution: 2015-2017’, Int’l J. Const. L. Blog, July 25, www.iconnectblog.com/2017/07/the-polish-revolution-2015-2017.

Sólyom, L. (2003), ‘The role of constitutional courts in the transition to democracy: with special reference to Hungary’, International Sociology, 18(1), 133-161.

Stone Sweet, A. ‘Constitutions and Judicial Power’, in D. Caramani (ed.) Comparative Politics, Oxford University Press: 217-239.

Sumption, L. (2016), ‘The limits of law’, in N. Barber, R. Ekins, and P. Yowell, Lord Sumption and the Limits of the Law, Hart.

Thornhill, C. (2019), ‘Constitutionalism and populism: national political integration and global legal integration’, International Theory, 12(1), 1-32.

Trencsenyi, B., M. Kopeček, L. L. Gabrijelčič, M. Falina, and M. Baár (eds) (2018), A History of Modern Political Thought in East Central Europe Volume II: Negotiating Modernity in the Short Twentieth Century and Beyond, Oxford University Press.

Vossen, K. (2011), ‘Classifying wilders: the Ideological development of Geert Wilders and his party for freedom’, Politics, 31(3), 179-189.

Wolff-Powęska, A. (2018), ‘Trommler der Revolution Jungkonservative und Polens Rechte’, Osteuropa, 3-5, 57-76.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
Bookmark and Share


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.