The Criminalization of Border Solidarity and the Law as a Double-Edged Weapon


Abstract


Criminalization of solidarity towards migrants at the external and internal borders of Europe is in full swing. It roots into the wider process of criminalisation of racialised foreigners and their mobility towards and within Europe, as well as into the increasing judicialization of direct activism and grassroots social movements on the ground of anti-terrorism. Law and society scholarship has grasped the complex relationship between legal institutions or tools and social movements, and how these latter can use Law as an offensive or defensive weapon to protect themselves and enhance their cause. Activists can also turn the weapon of Law against the State, when using repressive measures and trials as mediatic and political stages to launch general statements and denounce the State's inconsistency and law violations. Aiming at contributing to the understanding of the room and conditions to transform judicialization into a political weapon, the article investigates a peculiar case of criminalization of solidarity, namely the territorial bans issued by Italian police against "No Border" activists on the French-Italian border of Ventimiglia since 2015. It points out that, in spite of the annulment of the bans obtained by the defendants and their lawyers in court, the peculiar features of the repressive tool, of the social movement itself and of the context in which they occurred, strongly limited the possibility of a political reversal of judicialization. Crossing a legal opportunities framework with a legal consciousness perspective, the article also shows the plurality of activists' attitudes towards law and the effects of criminalization on activists' life paths.

DOI Code: 10.1285/i20356609v16i3p470

Keywords: Border; Solidarity; Criminalization; Legal mobilization; Legal consciousness

References


Abel R. (1998), “Speaking Law to Power. Occasions for Cause Lawyering” in A. Sarat and S. Scheingold (eds), Cause Lawyering: Political Commitments and Professional Responsibilities, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Agrikoliansky E. (2003), “Usages choisis du droit: le service juridique de la Ligue des Droits de l'Homme (1970-1990). Entre politique et raison humanitaire”, Sociétés contemporaines, 4(52): 61-84.

Bedeau H. (1961), “On civil disobedience”, Journal of philosophy, 58(21): 653-665.

Brandariz J. A. (2022), “Criminalization or instrumentalism? New trends in the field of border criminology”, Theoretical Criminology, 26(2): 285-303.

Bumiller, K. (1987), “Victims in the Shadow of the Law: A Critique of the Model of Legal Protection”, Signs, 12(3), 421–439.

Capitano Acab (2013), Mettere al bando. Storia ed evoluzione di una misura infame contro le ribellioni sociali e la dissidenza politica, Bologna: self-printed.

Carrera S., V. Mitsligeas, J. Allsopp, and L. Vosyliūtė (2019), Policing Humanitarianism. EU Policies against human smuggling and their impact on Civil Society, Oxford: Hart Publishing.

Chiaramonte X., A. Senaldi (2015), Criminalizzare i movimenti: i No Tav fra etichettamento e resistenza, Studi sulla questione criminale, 1: 105-144.

Codaccioni, V. (2013), “Expériences répressives et (dé)radicalisation militante. La variation des effets de la répression sur les jeunes membres du Parti communiste français (1947-1962)”, Cultures & Conflits, 1(89): 29-52.

Codaccioni V. (2021), “Empêcher, dépolitiser, punir: le triptyque de la répression politique”, Savoir/Agir, 55: 49-56.

Cowan D. (2004), “Legal Consciousness: Some Observations”, Modern Law Review, 67(6): 928-958.

della Porta D. (2020), “Building bridges: social movements and civil society in times of crisis”, Voluntas, 31(5): 938-948.

della Porta D., H. Reiter (2003), Polizia e protesta, Bologna: il Mulino.

della Porta D., E. Steinhilper (eds. 2021), Contentious Migrant Solidarity. Shrinking Spaces and Civil Society Contestation, London: Routledge.

Doherty B., G. Hayes (2015), “The Courts Criminal Trials as Strategic Arenas”, in J. Duyvendak, J. Jasper, J. (eds.) Breaking Down the State: Protestors Engaged, Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, 27-51.

Doherty B., G. Hayes (2012), “Having Your Day in Court: Judicial Opportunity and Tactical Choice in Anti-GMO Campaigns in France and the United Kingdom”, Comparative Political Studies, 47(1): 3-29.

Donini M. (2006), “Il diritto penale di fronte al ‘nemico’. Il riemergere del ‘nemico’ nelle politiche penali contemporanee”, Politiche criminali e penali, 2: 694-730.

du Jardin M. (2022), “Solidarité en Europe : état de l’art sur la criminalisation de l’aide aux personnes en situation irrégulière”, Déviance et Société, 4(46): 519-546.

Ewick P., S. Silbey (1992), “Conformity, Contestation, and Resistance: An Account of Legal Consciousness”, New England Law Review, 26(3): 731-749.

Fekete L. (2018), “Migrants, borders and the criminalisation of solidarity in the EU”, Race & Class, 59(4), 65-83.

Fleischmann L. (2020), ‘Contested Solidarity’, Practices of Refugee Support between Humanitarian Help and Political Activism, Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag.

Fritsvold E. D. (2009), “Under the Law: Legal Consciousness and Radical Environmental Activism”, Law & Social Inquiry, 34(4): 799-824.

Hamidi C. (2006), “Éléments pour une approche interactionniste de la politisation”, Revue française de science politique, 56, 5-25.

Hilson C. (2002), “New social movements: The role of legal opportunity”, Journal of European Public Policy, 9: 238-255:

Israël L. (2009), L’arme du droit, Paris: Presses de Sciences Po.

Israël L., J. Pélisse J. (2004), “Quelques éléments sur les conditions d'une « importation » (Note liminaire à la traduction du texte de S. Silbey et P. Ewick)”, Terrains & Travaux, 1(6): 101-111.

Jakobs G. (2014) (1985), “On the Theory of Enemy Criminal Law”, in M. D. Dubber (ed.), Foundational Texts in Modern Criminal Law, Oxford, Oxford Academic online.

Kolankiewicz M., M. Sager (2021), “Clandestine migration facilitation and border spectacle: criminalisation, solidarity, contestations”, Mobilities, 16(4), 584-596.

Lasalvia F. P. (2022), La prevenzione ragionevole. Le misure di prevenzione personali tra legalità e proporzionalità, Roma: Dike Giuridica Editrice.

Lendaro A. (2018), “Désobéir en faveur des migrants. Répertoires d’action à la frontière franco-italienne”, Journal des anthropologues, 1(152-153): 171-192.

Lendaro A. (2021), “Défendre les « délinquant·e·s solidaires ». Quelles sont les limites de l’engagement des avocat·e·s de la cause des étranger·e·s ?”, Droit et société, 107(1): 67-82.

Mariani E. (2021), Prevenire è meglio che punire. Le misure di prevenzione personali tra accertamento della pericolosità e bilanciamento di interessi, Milano: Giuffré Francis Lefebvre.

Martiìnez F. R. (2021) “The Constitutional Quality of Fraternity”, Revista Española de Derecho Constitucional, 123: 43–74.

Mathieu L. (2012), L’espace des mouvements sociaux, Bellecombe-en-Bauges: Éditions du Croquant.

McCann M. (1994), “Law and Social Movements”, in A. Sarat (ed.) The Blackwell Companion to Law and Society, Cambridge: Blackwell, 506-522.

McCann, M. (2021), “Law, Litigation, and the Politics of Social Movements”, e-legal, 5.

Musarò P., P. Parmiggiani (2018), “Taxi o ambulanze del mare? Politiche dell'immagine nella crisi dei migranti nel Mediterraneo”, Problemi dell'informazione, 1: 87-114.

Pali B. (2023), “A Criminology of Dis/Obedience?”, Critical Criminology, 31: 3–16.

Palidda S. (1999) “La criminalisation des migrants”, Actes de la recherche en sciences sociales, 129, 39-49.

Pélisse J. (2003), “Consciences du temps et consciences du droit chez des salariés à 35 heures”, Droit et société, 1(53): 163-186.

Pélisse J. (2005), “A-t-on conscience du droit ? Autour des Legal Consciousness Studies”, Genèses, 59, 114-130.

Poncibo C. (2021), “Life Story from the right-to-die movement in Italy”, e-legal, 5.

Reggiardo A. (2019), “Distrust and Stigmatization of NGOs and Volunteers at the time of the European Migrant ‘Crisis’”, PaCo, 12(2) : 460-486.

Sanchez G. (2017), “Critical Perspectives on Clandestine Migration Facilitation: An Overview of Migrant Smuggling Research”, Journal on Migration and Human Security, 5(1): 9–27.

Sarat A. (1990), “‘The Law Is All Over’: Power, Resistance and the Legal Consciousness of the Welfare Poor”, YJLH, 2(2): 343-380.

Sinatti G. (2019), “Humanitarianism as Politics: Civil Support Initiatives for Migrants in Milan’s Hub”, Social Inclusion, 7(2): 139-148

Solidarity Watch (2021), “The « solidarity crime » in the Maritime Alps: exploring the effects of criminal trials on migrant solidarity networks”, in Della Porta D., E. Steinhilper (eds.), Contentious Migrant Solidarity, London: Routledge, 216-235

Spiegel S. J. (2021), “Climate injustice, criminalisation of land protection and anti-colonial solidarity: Courtroom ethnography in an age of fossil fuel violence”, Political geography, 84.

Tazzioli M., W. Walters (2019), “Migration, solidarity and the limits of Europe”, Global Discourse, 9(1), 175-190.

Trucco D. (2016), “L’expérience du Presidio No Border à Vintimille, été 2015”, Mouvements.

Trucco D. (2021), “(Un)Politicising a European Border: No Border and Solidarity Mobilisations in Ventimiglia after 2015” in Amigoni L., S. Aru, I. Bonnin, G. Proglio and C. Vergnano (eds.) Debordering Europe. Movements and Control across the Ventimiglia Region, Palgrave McMillan, 179-204.

Trucco D. (2022), “Border town authorities and the multilevel politics of the ‘transit migrant’ emergency”, Territory, Politics, Governance, 10(3), 465-484.

Trucco D., K. Lamarche, and O. Philippe O. (2023), “À la frontière du droit : répertoire juridique et défense des exilé·es en territoire frontalier”, Droit et société, 113(1): 181-202.

Turk A. (1976), “Law as a Weapon in Social Conflict”, Social Problems, 23(3), 276-291.

Valenti C. (2010), Bobigny, le procès de l'avortement, Paris: Larousse.

Vandevoordt R. (2019), “Subversive humanitarianism : rethinking refugee solidarity through grass-roots initiatives”, Refugee Survey Quarterly, 38(3): 245–265.

Vanhala L. (2012), “Legal Opportunity Structures and the Paradox of Legal Mobilization by the Environmental Movement in the UK”, Law and Society Review, 6(3), 523-556.

Walters W. (2006), “No Border: Games With(out) Frontiers”, Social Justice, 33, 1(103), 21-39.

Zamponi L. (2017), “Practices of Solidarity: Direct Social Action, Politicisation and Refugee Solidarity Activism in Italy”, Mondi Migranti, n° 3, 97-117.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
Bookmark and Share


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.