Power and Resistance in the Neoliberal Age


Abstract


Aim of this work is trying to show, from a mainly theoretical standpoint but with constant ref-erences to Italian concrete cases, how neoliberalism, even though usually described as a State withdrawal from many issues left to individuals’ freedom, would actually represent an increase in forms of State inter-vention and control. The paper aims to analyze what forms this control may take, starting from current economic crisis, finding they are attributable to two scenarios: an explicit centralizing form, analyzed through the analytical tools of "state of exception" literature (Schmitt, Agamben); an implicit technical form, studied referring to the literature on "government through numbers" (Porter, Power, Miller, Es-peland, Desrosier). The paper also tries to show, once again through concrete examples, and by compari-son with Polanyi’s analysis of resistance to ‘900 classical liberalism, how behind the two neoliberal power there would be the same strength to impose to consciences, and most of all what would be the conse-quences of this for the possibility for social movements to try to deconstruct neoliberalism’s discourse, and to challenge it by collective action.
medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical medical

DOI Code: 10.1285/i20356609v9i2p358

Keywords: Neoliberalism; power; quantification; resistance; state of exception

References


Agamben (2003), Stato di eccezione, Torino: Bollati Boringhieri

Appadurai A. (2013), Future as a cultural fact, Verso

Arnold P.J. (2009), “Institutional Perspectives on the Internationalization of Account-ing”, in Chapman C. et al. (eds. 2009), 48-64

Baccaro L., Howell C. (2011), “A Common Neoliberal Trajectory”, Politics and Society, 39:521-563

Benford R.D., Snow D.A. (2000), “Framing Processes and Social Movements”, Annual Review of Sociology, 26:611-639

Berland N., Chiapello E. (2009), “Criticisms of capitalism, budgeting and the double en-rolment”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 34:28-57

Blondiaux L., Sintomer Y. (2002), “L’impératif délibératif”, Politix, 57:17-35

Boltanski L., Chiapello E. (2005), The New Spirit of Capitalism, London: Verso

Boltanski L., Thévenot L. (2006), On Justification, Princeton: Princeton UP

Bonetti P., Cardone A., Cassatella A. (eds. 2014), Spazio della tecnica e spazio del potere nella tutela dei diritti sociali, Roma: Aracne

Borghi V. (2011), “La presa della rete”, in Rivista Italiana di Sociologia, 3:445-460

Borraz O. (2009), “Le norme”, in Lascoumes P., Le Galès P. (eds.2009), 37-72

Brunkhorst H. (2008), Habermas, Firenze, UP

Bruno I. (2009), “The Indefinite Discipline of Competitiveness Benchmarking as a Ne-oliberal Technology of Government”, Minerva, 47(3):261-280

Buffoni L. (2014), “Il nomos del mercato tra concorrenza e diritti sociali”, in Bonetti P. et al. (eds.2014), 331-385

Cabiddu M. (2010), “Stato di eccezione”, Amministrazione in cammino, 26/07/10

Cain B., Dalton R., Scarrow S. (eds.2006), Democracy Transformed?, Oxford: OUP

Callon M. (ed.1998), The Laws of the Markets, Oxford: Blackwell

Callon M, Lascoumes P., Barthe Y. (2009), Acting in an Uncertain World, Boston: MIT

Carrer M. (2014), “Vincoli europei per la costituzionalizzazione del ciclo economico”, in Bonetti P. et al. (eds.2014), 821-848

Castel R. (2003), L’insécurité sociale, Paris: Seuil

Cata Baker L. (2002), “Global Panopticism”, Journal of Global Legal Studies, 15

Centemeri L. (2012), Reframing incommensurability in environmental valuation, “Em-beddedness and beyond”, Moscow 25th-28th October 2012

Cerruto M., Facello C. (2013), “Competizione e interessi”, in Morlino L., Piana D., Raniolo F. (eds.2013), La qualità della democrazia in Italia, Bologna: Il Mulino, 76-94

Chapman C., Cooper D., Miller P. (eds.2009), Accounting, Organizations, and Institu-tions, Oxford: Oxford UP

Chelli M., Gendron Y. (2013), “Sustainability Ratings and the Disciplinary Power of the Ideology of Numbers”, Journal of Business Ethics, 112(2):187-203

Cortese F. (2014), “Governo della crisi, spesa pubblica e diritti sociali tra diritto globale e ordinamento statale”, in Bonetti P. et al. (eds.2014), 799-820

Crouch C. (2003), Postdemocrazia, Roma-Bari: Laterza

Daly H., Cobb J. (2007), “Reply to R. Ziegler”, Environmental Values, 16:287-288

Dalton R. (2004), Democratic Challenges, Democratic Choices, Oxford: Oxford UP

Dani M. (2013), Il diritto pubblico europeo nella prospettiva dei conflitti, Padova: Ce-dam

Davies W. (2010), Neoliberalism, Rising Powers and Property Rights, RP-WP

Davis K., Kingsbury B., Merry S. (2012), “Indicators as a Technology of Global Govern-ance”, Law and Society Review, 46:71-104

De Leonardis O. (2008), “Nuovi conflitti a Flatlandia”, in G. Grossi (ed.), Conflitti con-temporanei, Torino: Utet

De Leonardis O. (2010), “Incastrati nella partecipazione”, in Alecci E., Bottaccio M. (eds.), Fuori dall’angolo, Napoli: Ancora, 95-96

De Leonardis O. (2015), “Welfare, poteri forti, democrazia debole”, Sbilanciamoci, 55

Desrosières A. (2011), “Il ruolo del numero nel governo della città neoliberale”, Rasse-gna Italiana di Sociologia, 3:373-397

Donolo C. (2004), “Notizie sul governo di Babilonia”, in Marcelloni N. (ed.), Questioni della città contemporanea, Milano: FrancoAngeli

Espeland W. (1997), “Authority by the Numbers”, Law & Social Inquiry, 22(4):1107-1133

Espeland W., Sauder M. (2007), “Rankings and Reactivity”, American Journal of Sociol-ogy, 113:1-40

Espeland W., Stevens M. (1998), “Commensuration as a Social Process”, Annual Review of Sociology, 24:313-343

Espeland W., Vannebo B. (2007), “Accountability, Quantification, and Law”, Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 3:21-43

Formenti C. (2008), Utopie postdemocratiche e nuovi media, Milano: Cortina

Funnell, W. (2007), “Accounting and the Virtues of Anarchy”, Australasian Accounting Business Journal, 1(1)

Fusaro C. (2012), “La formazione del governo Monti”, Quaderni costituzionali, 2:391-394

Garapon A. (2012), Lo Stato minimo, Milano: Cortina

Gibbon P., Henriksen L. (2012), “A Standard Fit for Neoliberalism”, Comparative Studies in Society and History, 54(2):275-307

Grossberg L. (2010), “Modernity and Commensuration”, Cultural Studies, 24(3):295-332

Gualmini E. (2012), Concertazione buon metodo, non rito imprescindibile, “Il Sole 24 Ore”, 13/03/2012

Hacking I. (1982), “Biopower and the Avalanche of Printed Numbers”, Humanities in Society, 5:279-295

Hansen H., Porter T. (2012), “What Do Numbers Do in Transnational Governance?”, International Political Sociology, 6(4):409-426

Harvey D. (2007), Brief History of Neoliberalism, Oxford: Oxford UP

Hibbing J., Theiss-Morse E. (2002), Stealth democracy, New York: Cambridge UP

Hibou B. (2015), The Bureaucratization of the World in the Neoliberal Era, London: Pal-grave

Hendriks C.M. (2002), “Institutions of Deliberative Democratic Processes and Interest Groups”, Australian Journal of Public Administration, 1:64-75

Inglehart R. (1999), “Postmodernization Erodes Respect for Authority, But Increases Support for Democracy”, in Norris P. (ed.1999), 237-277

Krever T., “Legal Indicator Projects and the Reproduction of Neoliberal Common Sense”, Third World Quarterly, 34

Lamont M. (2012), “Toward a Comparative Sociology of Valuation and Evaluation”, An-nual Review of Sociology, 38:201-221

Lascoumes P., Le Galès P. (eds.2009), Gli strumenti per governare, Milano: Bruno Mondadori

Lambert C., Pezet E. (2012), “Accounting and the Making of Homo Liberalis”, Foucault Studies, 13:67-81

Lastrico V. (2013), “Quando il forum sostituisce la fabbrica”, Sociologia della Comunicazione, 46:95-112

Lastrico V. (2014a), “Rappresentazioni della rappresentanza”, in Armano E., Murgia A. (eds.), Generazione precaria, nuovi lavori e processi di soggettivazione, Bologna, Odoya, 167-183

Lastrico V. (2014b), Conflitti ambientali come conflitti di valore, WP-LPF, 7/2014

Lastrico V. (2015a), Tecnocrazia come egemonia valoriale depoliticizzata, WP-LPF, 6/2015

Lastrico V. (2015b), “La rivendicazione del diritto dell’abitare”, Welfare e Ergonomia, 1:35-46

Lastrico V. (2015c), “L’eccezione come regola”, Rivista Italiana di

Politiche Pubbliche, 3:279-308

Lastrico V., Gasparini M.F. (2014), “Il diritto ad un ambiente salubre tra standard di tu-tela e discrezionalità nell’utilizzo degli standard”, in Bonetti P. et al. (eds.2014), 273-308

Lanzalaco L. (2015), “Power of Global Finance and Weakness of Political Institutions”, RIPP, 2:255-275

Lo Schiavo L. (2014), Ontologia critica del Presente, Milano: Mimesis

Lovink G. (2011), Networks Without a Cause, Cambridge: Polity

Marazzita G. (2011), “L’irresistibile tentazione del potere di ordinanza”, Osservatorio sulle fonti, 2:1-55

Marx U. (2013), The problematization and translation of gender budgeting, MBA

Meynaud J. (1966), La tecnocrazia, Roma-Bari: Laterza

Miller P., O’Leary T. (1987), “Accounting and the Construction of the Governable Per-son”, Accounting, Organizations and Society, 12:235-265

Montedoro G. (2012), “Mercati, democrazia e potere costituente”, ApertaContrada, 08/03/2012

Negrelli A. (2014), “Liberalizzazione e tutela dei diritti sociali”, in Bonetti P. et al. (eds.2014), 309-330

Negri A. (2012), “A proposito delle lotte in Val di Susa”, Uninomade, 07/03/2012.

Norris P. (ed.1999), Critical Citizens, Oxford, Oxford UP

Nye J., Zelikow P., King D. (1997), Why people don’t trust Government, Cambridge, Harvard UP

OECD (2001), Coinvolgere i cittadini nella presa di decisione, Oecd notes, 10

Ogden S.G. (1995), “Transforming frameworks of accountability”, Accounting, Organi-zations and Society, 20:193-218

Parmigiani F., “Criticità formali e sostanziali dell’introduzione del pareggio di bilancio in Costituzione”, in Bonetti P. et al. (eds.2014), 849-870

Perry-Kessaris A. (2011), “Prepare your indicators”, International Journal of Law in Context, 7(4):401-421

Pettit P. (2004), “Depoliticizing Democracy”, Ratio Juris, 17(1):52-65

Pharr S., Putnam R. (eds.2000), Disaffected Democracies, Princeton: Princeton UP

Piazza G. (2011),“Locally unwanted land use movements”, Modern Italy, 16(3):329-344

Piazza J. (2001), “De-linking Labour”, Party Politics, 4:413–35

Piccio D.R. (2014), “Party feminisation from below”, in K. Celis, S. Childs (eds.), Gender, Conservatism and Women’s Political Representation, ECPR Press

Piller I., Cho J. (2013), “Neoliberalism as language policy”, Language in Society, 42:23-44

Pinson G. (2009), “Il progetto come strumento d’azione pubblica urbana”, in Lascou-mes P., Le Galès P. (eds.2009), 107-148

Polanyi K. (2000)[1944], La grande trasformazione, Torino: Einaudi

Poppy J. (2013), “The biopolitics of the Quantified Self in the age of neoliberalism”, Transfigure Project, 11(6)

Porter T. (2007), “The Rise of Cost-Benefit Rationality as Solution to a Political Problem of Distrust”, Research in Law and Economics, 23:337-344

Rancière J. (2007), L’odio per la democrazia, Napoli: Cronopio

Romano S. (1918), L’ordinamento giuridico, Pisa: Spoerri

Rosga A., Satterthwaie M., “The Trust in Indicators”, Berkley Journal of International Law, 27(2):253-315

Rouvroy A., Berns T. (2010), “Le nouveau pouvoir statistique”, Multitudes, 40(1):88-103

Rui S. (2004), La démocratie en débat, Paris: Colin

Sabel C. F. (2001), A Quiet Revolution of Democratic Governance, OECD

Salais R. (2012), “Labour and the politics of freedom”, in De Leonardis O., Negrelli S., Salais R., Democracy and capabilities for voice, Bruxelles: Peter Lang, 227-244

Sandulli M. (2008), “Introduzione all’art.20 del D.L.185/2008”, Federalismi, 23

Sauder M., Espeland W. (2009), “The Discipline of Rankings”, American Sociological Review, 74(1):63-82

Sauder M., Lancaster R. (2006), “Do Rankings Matter?”, Law & Society Review, 40(1):105-134

Schmitt C. (1972) [1927], Le categorie del politico, Bologna: Il Mulino

Schön D., Rein M. (1994), Frame Reflection, New York: Basic

Scotto G. (2008), Riflessioni su stato di eccezione e sovranità, Roma: Aracne

Sikka P., Willmott H. (2009), “All Offshore”, in Chapman C. et al. (eds.2009), 396-414

Simoncini R. (2008), “Lo stato di eccezione secondo Agamben”, Diritto e Questioni Pubbliche, VIII(8):197-211

Snow D., Benford R. (1992), “Master frames and cycles of protest”, in A. Morris, C. Mueller (eds.), Frontiers in Social Movement Theory, New Haven: Yale UP, 133-155

Sukys P.(2010), Neoliberalism and the Unethical Dimension of Market Ethic, PPForum

Supiot A. (2011), Lo spirito di Filadelfia, Roma: Et Al

Supiot A. (2015), La gouvernance par les nombres, Paris: Fayard

Thévenot L. (2011), “Autorità e poteri alla prova della critica”, Rassegna Italiana di So-ciologia, 4:627-660

Urbinati N. (2015), “La marcia dei ricchi”, Sbilanciamoci, 55

Zamponi L.(2013), “Why don’t Italians Occupy”, Social Movement Studies, 11: 416-426


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.