From Availability to Accessibility. Vaccination Proximity in a Social Clinic in Palermo


Abstract


The present paper explores protests and initiatives in the vaccination field carried out by organisations developed within social movements, specifically focusing on the collective social actors involved in the Covid-19 vaccination campaign by proposing differentiated intervention strategies to ensure equity in access to the vaccine. The case study is the social clinic of Borgovecchio (Palermo) which developed a vaccination centre that responds to the principles of Primary Health Care (accessible, proactive and inspired by a spirit of 'proximity'). The social clinic is located in the community centre Anomalia. Data collection was carried out through observation and semi-structured interviews. The so-called 'proximity vaccine centre' project results from the radical criticism of the official vaccination campaign. The paper analyses the distinctive elements between this grassroots initiative and the official vaccination campaign, the initiative's guiding principles and goals, the organisational aspects and the ambivalences of the relationship with institutions. The results suggest that the primary goal of the "grassroots vaccine centre" was to safeguard the inhabitants of the district through a 're-territorialisation' of the intervention and the valorisation of different elements such as relation, spatial proximity and "trust". Additionally, the involvement of the social clinic in the vaccination campaigns represents an unprecedented collaboration between the National Health System and an informal organisation. Consequently, this case study represents a privileged observation point for analysing the relationships and conflicts between a self-organised experience and governmental institutions. Finally, this contribution suggests a broad reflection on the processes of politicisation in the healthcare domain and on the risk that initiatives implemented in an emergency logic produce or reinforce further inequalities in access to services.

DOI Code: 10.1285/i20356609v15i3p614

Keywords: Vaccination campaign; Covid-19; Primary Health Care; Health social movements; vaccine hesitancy

References


Ambrosini M. (2015), “NGOs and Health Services for Irregular Immigrants in Italy: When the Protection of Human Rights Challenges the Laws”, Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies, 13(2): 116-134.

André C., P. Batifoulier, and J. Jansen-Ferreira (2016), “Health care privatization processes in Europe: Theoretical justifications and empirical classification”, Int. Soc. Seec. Review, 69(1): 3-23.

Aw J., J. J. B. Seng, S.S.Y. Seah, and L.L. Low (2021), “Covid-19 Vaccine Hesitancy - A Scoping Review of Literature in High-Income Countries”, Vaccines, 9(8):900.

Azzolina L., E. Pavolini (2012), “La sanità alla prova nelle regioni del Sud”, Il Mulino, 462(4): 618-625.

Bambra C., R. Riordan, J. Ford, and F. Matthews (2020), “The Covid-19 pandemic and health inequalities”, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 74(11): 964-968.

Bedford H., K. Attwell, M. Danchin, H. Marshall, et al. (2018), “Vaccine hesitancy, refusal and access barriers: The need for clarity in terminology”, Vaccine, 36(44): 6556-6558.

Bertin G., C. Cipolla (2013), Verso differenti sistemi sanitari regionali, Venezia: Edizioni CaFoscari.

Bertoncello C., A. Ferro, M. Fonzo, S. Zanovello, G. Napoletano, F. Russo, V. Baldo, and S. Cocchio (2020), “Socioeconomic Determinants in Vaccine Hesitancy and Vaccine Refusal in Italy”, Vaccines, 8(2): 276.

Betsch C., R. Böhm, and G.B. Chapman (2015), “Using Behavioral Insights to Increase Vaccination Policy Effectiveness”, Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2(1): 61-73.

Betsch C., P. Schmid, D. Heinemeier, L. Korn, C. Holtmann, and R. Böhm (2018) “Beyond confidence: Development of a measure assessing the 5C psychological antecedents of vaccination”, PLoS ONE, 13(12).

Borrelli G., F. Sparano (2021), Prendersi cura delle persone. Viaggio tra gli ambulatori popolari. Revised January 1, 2021, Retrieved April 5, 2022 (https://altreconomia.it/viaggio-tra-gli-ambulatori-popolari/).

Braveman P., S. Gruskin (2003), “Defining equity in health”, Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 57(4): 254-258.

Brenner S., V. Lok (2022), “«We assist the health system doing the work that should be done by others»– a qualitative study on experiences of grassroots level organizations providing refugee health care during the 2015 migration event in Germany”, BMC Health Serv Res., 22(309): 1-18.

Burgess R.A., R.H. Osborne, K.A. Yongabi, et al. (2021), “The Covid-19 vaccines rush: participatory community engagement matters more than ever”, Lancet, 2: 8-10.

Burky T. (2021), “Global Covid-19 vaccine inequity”, The Lancet Infectious Disease, 21(7): 922-923.

Burström B., W. Tao (2020), “Social determinants of health and inequalities in Covid-19”, European Journal of Public Health, 30(4): 617-618.

Busso S., N. De Luigi (2019), “Civil Society Actors and the Welfare State. A historically-based analytical framework”, Partecipazione e conflitto, 12(2):259-296.

Cabot H. (2016), “Contagious’ solidarity: reconfiguring care and citizenship in Greece's social clinics”, Social Anthropology, 24(2): 152-166.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2022), “Johnson & Johnson’s Janssen Covid-19 Vaccine Overview and Safety”. Revised April 4, 2022, Retrieved May 10, 2022 (https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/different-vaccines/janssen.html#print).

Chiolero A., S. Cullati, and V. Santschi (2021), “Primary healthcare for a long term and sustainable vaccination strategy”, British Medical Journal, 372(650).

Commission on Social Determinants of Health (2009), Closing the gap in a generation: health equity through action on the social determinants of health. Final Report of the Commission on Social Derminants of Health, Ginevra: WHO.

Cueto M. (2004), “The origins of primary health care and selective primary health care”, American journal of public health, 94(11): 1864-74.

Daskin M.S., L.K. Dean (2004), “Location of Health Care Facilities”, in M. Brandeau, F. Sainfort, and W. Pierskalla (eds), Handbook of OR/MS in Health Care: A Handbook of Methods and Applications, New York: Kluwer, pp. 43-76.

Dubé E., C. Laberge, M. Guay, P. Bramadat, R. Réal, and J. Bettingeret (2013) “Vaccine hesitancy: an overview”, Human Vaccines & Immunotherapeutics, 9(8): 1763-1773.

Dubé, E., J.K. Ward, P. Verger, and N. E. MacDonald (2021), “Vaccine Hesitancy, Acceptance, and Anti-Vaccination: Trends and Future Prospects for Public Health”, Annu. Rev. Public Health, 42:175-191.

Farris, S., S. Marchetti (2017), “From the Commodification to the Corporatization of Care: European Perspectives and Debates”, Social Politics, 24(2):109-131.

Freidson E. (2002), La dominanza medica. Le basi sociali della malattia e delle istituzioni sanitarie, Milano: FrancoAngeli.

Gallé F., E. A. Sabella, P. Roma, G. Da Molinet, et al. (2021), “Acceptance of Covid-19 Vaccination in the Elderly: A Cross-Sectional Study in Southern Italy”, Vaccines, 9(11):1222.

Ghiglione G. (2018), L’ambulatorio a Milano che cura migranti e senza dimora, Revised July 2, 2018, Retrieved May 2, 2022 (https://www.internazionale.it/reportage/giorgioghiglione/2018/07/02/ambulatorio-medico-popolare-milano)

Giddens A. (1990), The Consequences of Modernity, Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Gish O. (1982), “Selective Primary Care: Old Wine in New Bottles” Social Science and Medicine, 16(1054): 1049-1054.

Gobo, G., B. Sena (2019), “Oltre la polarizzazione “pro-vax” versus “no-vax”. Atteggiamenti e motivazioni nel dibattito italiano sulle vaccinazioni”, Salute e Società, 18(2): 176-90.

Horton R. (2020), “Offline: Covid-19 is not a pandemic”, The Lancet, 396(10255):874.

Iqbal Z., R. Chambers (2009), “Is it time to take primary care seriously in redressing health inequalities?” Qual Prim Care,17(4): 243-245.

Javanparast S., F. Baum, A. Ziersch, and T. Freeman (2022), “A Framework to Determine the Extent to Which Regional Primary Healthcare Organisations Are Comprehensive or Selective in Their Approach”, Int. J. of Health Policy and Management, 11(4): 479-488.

Khan M. S., S.A. Ali Moshin, A. Addy, and A. Karan (2022), “Rethinking vaccine hesitancy among minority groups”, The Lancet, 397(10288):1863-1865.

Kokkinidis G., M. Checchi (2021), “Power matters: Posthuman entanglements in a social solidarity clinic”, Organization, pp.1-19.

Kumar D., R. Chandra, M. Mathur, S. Samdariya, and N. Kapoor (2016), “Vaccine hesitancy: understanding better to address better”, Israel Journal of Health Policy Research, 5(2): 1-8.

McDonald D. A., G. Ruiters (2012), Alternatives to privatization. Public options for essential services in the Global South, CapeTown: HSRC Press.

Matteini C. (2021), Irregolari e homeless: gli invisibili del vaccino, Revised July 20, 2021, Retrieved April 27, 2022 (https://www.fondazioneveronesi.it/magazine/articoli/da-non-perdere/irregolari-e-homeless-gli-invisibili-del-vaccino#section-0).

McClure E.S., P. Vasudevan, P., Z. Bailey, et al. (2020), “Racial capitalism within public health—how occupational settings drive Covid-19 disparities”, Am J Epidemiol, 189:1244-53.

Magnussen L., J. Ehiri, and P. Jolly (2004), “Comprehensive versus selective primary health care: lessons for global health policy”, Health affairs, 23(3):167-176.

Meyer S., P. Ward, J. Coveney, and W. Rogers (2008) “Trust in the health system: An analysis and extension of the social theories of Giddens and Luhmann”, Health Sociology Review, 17(2):177-186

Musolino C., F. Baum, T. Freeman, R. Labonté, et al. (2020), “Global health activists’ lessons on building social movements for Health for All”, Int. Journ. for Equity in Health, 19(116).

Neri S. (2020), “Più Stato e più Regioni. L'evoluzione della governance del Servizio sanitario nazionale e la pandemia” Autonomie Locali e Servizi Sociali, 2:239-255.

Norbury M., S.W. Mercer, J. Gillies, J. Furler, and G.C. Watt (2011), “Time to care: tackling health inequalities through primary care”, Fam Pract., 28(1):1-3.

Pecile V. (2017), “Urban Mobilisations in a Post-Crisis Mediterranean City. The Case of Commons in Palermo”, Comparative Law Review, 8(1): 1-16.

Pinaka O., I. Spanou, V. Papadouli, E. Papanikolau, F. Gioulekas, and V. Mouchtouri (2021), “The role of local primary healthcare units in increasing immunization uptake among children in vulnerable social groups through vaccination campaigns”, Public Health in Practice, 2:100185.

Rasanathan K., E.V. Montesinos, D. Matheson, et al. (2011), “Primary health care and the social determinants of health: essential and complementary approaches for reducing inequities in health”, J Epidemiol Community Health, 65(8): 656-60.

Ratzan S., E. Schneider, H. Hatch, and J. Cacchione, (2021), “Missing the Point - How Primary Care Can Overcome Covid-19 Vaccine Hesitancy”, N Engl J Med, 384.

Rhodes R., J.J. Strain (2000), “Trust and transforming medical institutions”, Camb Q Healthc Ethics, 9(2): 205-217.

Roozen G.V.T., A.H.E. Roukens, and M. Roestenberg (2022), “Covid-19 vaccine dose sparing: strategies to improve vaccine equity and pandemic preparedness”, The Lancet Global Health, 10(4): 570-57.

Reno C., E. Maietti, M.P. Fantini, et al. (2021), “Enhancing Covid-19 Vaccines Acceptance: Results from a Survey on Vaccine Hesitancy in Northern Italy”, Vaccines, 9(378).

Rifkin S.B., G. Walt (1986), “Why health improves: defining the issues concerning 'comprehensive primary health care' and 'selective primary health care”, Soc Sci Med, 23(6): 559-66.

Shapiro G. K., O. Tatar, E. Dubé, R. Amsel, B. Knauper., A. Naz, S. Perez and Z. Rosberger (2018), “The vaccine hesitancy scale: Psychometric properties and validation”, Vaccine, 36(5): 660-667.

Siino A.R. (2021), “The Covid-19 Emergency and the Risk of Social Fragmentation in the Palermo Case”, Front. Sociol., 5:624160.

Singer M., S. Clair (2003), “Syndemics and public health: reconceptualizing disease in bio-social context”, Medical Anthropology, 17(4): 423-44.

Società Italiana di Medicina delle Migrazioni, Tavolo Immigrazione e Salute (2021), Piano strategico vaccinale, il Tavolo Immigrazione e Salute scrive al Ministro Speranza: ecco le misure per raggiungere le persone vulnerabili e socialmente fragili a garanzia di tutti”, Revised February 16, 2021, Retrieved May 15, 2022 (https://www.simmweb.it/attachments/article/1017/CS-Piano%20strategico%20vaccinale%20Proposte%20TIS.pdf)

Sorell T., J. Butler (2022), “The Politics of Covid Vaccine Hesitancy and Opposition”, The Political Quarterly, 93(2): 347-351.

Starfield B., L. Shi, and J. Macinko (2005), “Contribution of primary care to health systems and health”, Milbank Quarterly, 83(3): 457-502.

Starfield B. (2009), “Primary Care and Equity in Health: The Importance to Effectiveness and Equity of Responsiveness to Peoples’ Needs”, Humanity & Society, 33(1-2):56-73

Stefanini A., C. Bodini (2014), “Salute e partecipazione della comunità. Una questione politica”, Sistema Salute, 58(3):308-315.

Storer E., I. Sarafian, C. Torre, S. Vallerani and E. Franchi (2022), “COVID-19 vaccination campaigns and the production of mistrust among Roma and migrant populations in Italy”, BMJ Global Health, 7.

Streefland P., A.M.R. Chowdhury, and P. Ramos-Jimenez (1999), “Patterns of vaccination acceptance”,Social Science and Medicine, 49:1705-16.

Strully K. W., T.M. Harrison, T.A. Pardo, and C. Jordan (2021), “Strategies to Address Covid-19 Vaccine Hesitancy and Mitigate Health Disparities in Minority Populations”, Frontiers in Public Health ,9.

Troiano G., A. Nardi (2021), “Vaccine hesitancy in the era of Covid-19”, Public Health, 194: 245-251.

Walsh J. A., M.D. Warren (1979), “Selective Primary Health Care - An Interim Strategy for Disease Control in Developing Countries”, N Engl J Med, 301: 967-974.

Wang Z., K. Tang (2020), “Combating Covid-19: health equity matters”, Nature medicine, 26(4): 458.

Ward P., A. Coates (2006), “We shed tears, but there is no one there to wipe them up for us’: narratives of (mis)trust in a materially deprived community”, Health,10(3): 283-301.

Warren R.C., L. Forrow, D.A. Hodge, and R.D. Truog (2020), “Trustworthiness before trust - Covid-19 vaccine trials and the Black community”, N Engl J Med, 383(22):121.

Willis D. E., J.A. Andersen, K. Bryant-Moore, et al. (2021), “Covid‐19 vaccine hesitancy: Race/ethnicity, trust, and fear”, Clinical and Translational Science, 14(6): 2200-2207.

WHO (1978), Declaration of Alma-Ata, Ginevra: WHO.

WHO (2008), Primary health care. Now more than ever, Ginevra: WHO.

WHO (2014), Report of the SAGE Working Group on Vaccine Hesitancy, Geneva: WHO.

WHO (2019), Ten Threats to Global Health in 2019, Geneva: WHO

Wiysonge C.S., D. Ndwandwe, J. Ryan, et al. (2022), “Vaccine hesitancy in the era of Covid-19: could lessons from the past help in divining the future?”, Hum Vaccin Immunother, 18(1): 1-3.

Yin R. K. (2003), Case study research: Design and methods, Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
Bookmark and Share


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.