Is Democracy Effective against Coronavirus? An Analysis of Citizens' Opinions in Italy


Abstract


The social and political implications of the COVID-19 pandemic are receiving increasing attention in the literature. This article aims to contribute to this fast-growing research programme by focusing on the degree to which Italian citizens perceive democratic institutions as effective in coping with crises like the COVID-19 emergency. We put forward a set of hypotheses whereby negative evaluations of the effectiveness of democracy can be associated with social proximity to the disease and with perceived health and economic threats. We also argued that political factors can interact with such threats. Moreover, we hypothesised that certain factors dealing with the concepts of social capital and civic culture can help inhibit negative opinions about the effectiveness of democracy. To test these hypotheses, we analysed public opinion data collected in Italy between April and July 2020 using a Rolling Cross-Section survey design. The data showed that evaluations of democracy became more negative with social proximity to the disease and with individual perceived vulnerability, understood in health and economic terms. Our findings also highlighted that certain social factors which "underpin" democracy moderated negative evaluations. Finally, political factors like ideology and government appraisal shaped the relationship between individual threats and evaluations of democracy.

DOI Code: 10.1285/i20356609v14i1p176

Keywords: COVID-19; Democracy; Economic insecurity; Health threat; Rolling Cross-Section

References


Almond G.A., and S. Verba (1963), The Civic Culture: Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five Nations, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Amat F., A. Arenas, A. Falcó-Gimeno, and J. Muñoz (2020), “Pandemics Meet Democracy. Experimental Evidence from the COVID-19 Crisis in Spain”, SocArXiv, 6 April, https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/dkusw/.

Anderson, C.J., A. Blais, S. Bowler, T. Donovan, and O. Listhaug, eds, (2005), Losers’ Consent: Elections and Democratic Legitimacy, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Armingeon K., and K. Guthmann (2014), “Democracy in Crisis? The Declining Support for National Democracy in European Countries, 2007-2011”, European Journal of Political Research, 53(3): 423–42.

Baekgaard M., J. Christensen, J.K. Madsen, and K.S. Mikkelsen (2020), “Rallying Around the Flag in Times of COVID-19: Societal Lockdown and Trust in Democratic Institutions”, Journal of Behavioral Public Administration, 3(2).

Barbieri P., and B. Bonini (2020), “Populism and Political (Mis-) Belief Effect on Individual Adherence to Lockdown during the COVID-19 Pandemic in Italy”, available at

https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3640324.

Bol D., M. Giani, A. Blais, and P.J. Loewen (2020), “The Effect of COVID-19 Lockdowns on Political Support: Some Good News for Democracy?”, European Journal of Political Research, https://ejpr.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1475-6765.12401.

Bøggild T., and C. Jenssen (2020), “Reappraisal and Extensions of the Rally ‘Round the Flag Effect: Longitudinal Evidence from the COVID-19 Crisis”, Working Paper.

Brooks S.K., R.K. Webster, L.E. Smith, L. Woodland, S. Wessely, N. Greenberg, and G.J. Rubin (2020), “The Psychological Impact of Quarantine and How to Reduce It: Rapid Review of the Evidence”, The Lancet, 395(10227): 912-920.

Calvillo D.P., B.J. Ross, R.J. Garcia, T.J. Smelter, and A.M. Rutchick (2020), “Political Ideology Predicts Perceptions of the Threat of COVID-19 (and Susceptibility to Fake News About It)”, Social Psychological and Personality Science, 11(8): 1119-1128.

Cordero G., and P. Simón (2016), “Economic Crisis and Support for Democracy in Europe”, West European Politics, 39(2): 305–25.

Curini L., W. Jou, and V. Memoli (2012), “Satisfaction with Democracy and the Winner/Loser Debate: The Role of Policy Preferences and Past Experience”, British Journal of Political Science, 42(2): 241–261.

Dalton R.J. (2004), Democratic Challenges, Democratic Choices, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Daoust J.F., and R. Nadeau (2020), “Context Matters: Economics, Politics and Satisfaction with Democracy”, Electoral Studies, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.electstud.2020.102133.

Delia P.F. (2020), “Cross-Cultural Differences In Risk Perception And Risk Communication. A Case Study On The Covid-19 Outbreak”, Redefining Community In Intercultural Context, 9(1): 68-74.

Devine D., J. Gaskell, W. Jennings, and G. Stoker (2020), “Trust and the Coronavirus Pandemic: What are the Consequences of and for Trust? An Early Review of the Literature”, Political Studies Review, https://doi.org/10.1177/1478929920948684.

De Vries C., B.N. Bakker, S.B. Hobolt, and K. Arcenaux (2021), “Crisis Signaling: How Italy’s Coronavirus Lockdown Affected Incumbent Support in Other European Countries”, Political Science Research and Methods, https://doi.org/10.1017/psrm.2021.6.

Dinesen P.T., and M.M. Jæger (2013), “Effect of Terror on Institutional Trust”, Political Psychology, 34: 917-926.

Dryhurst S., C.R. Schneider, J. Kerr, A.L.J. Freeman, G. Recchia, A.M. van der Bles, D. Spiegelhalter, S. van der Linden (2020), “Risk Perceptions of COVID-19 Around the World”, Journal of Risk Research, 23(7-8): 994-1006.

Easton D. (1975), “A Re-Assessment of the Concept of Political Support”, British Journal of Political Science, 5(4): 435–457.

Esaiasson P., J. Sohlberg, M. Ghersetti, and B. Johansson (2020), “How the Coronavirus Crisis Affects Citizen Trust in Institutions and in Unknown Others: Evidence from ‘the Swedish experiment’”, European Journal of Political Research,

https://ejpr.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1475-6765.12419.

Ferrin M., and H. Kriesi, eds, (2016), How Europeans View and Evaluate Democracy, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Flinders M. (2020), “Democracy and the Politics of Coronavirus: Trust, Blame and Understanding”, Parliamentary Affairs, https://doi.org/10.1093/pa/gsaa013.

Goldstein D., and J. Wiedemann (2020), “Who Do You Trust? The Consequences of Political and Social Trust for Public Responsiveness to COVID-19 Orders”, available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3580547 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3580547.

Guglielmi S., G.M. Dotti Sani, F. Molteni, F. Biolcati, A.M. Chiesi, R. Ladini, M. Maraffi, A. Pedrazzani, and C. Vezzoni (2020), “Public Acceptability of Containment Measures during the COVID-19 Pandemic in Italy: How Institutional Confidence and Specific Political Support Matter”, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 40(9/10): 1069-1085.

Han Q., B. Zheng, M. Cristea, M. Agostini, J. Belanger, B. Gutzkow, J. Kreienkamp, and P. Leander (2020), “Trust in Government and Its Associations with Health Behaviour and Prosocial Behaviour during the COVID-19 Pandemic”, PsyArXiv Preprints.

https://psyarxiv.com/p5gns/.

Hopkin J. (2020), Anti-System Politics: The Crisis of Market Liberalism in Rich Democracies, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Inglehart R. (1990), Culture Shift in Advanced Industrial Society, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Inglehart R. (1997), Modernization and Postmodernization: Cultural, Economic and Political Change in 43 Societies, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Jennings W. (2020), COVID-19 and the ‘Rally-Round-the Flag’ Effect, https://ukandeu.ac.uk/covid-19-and-the-rally-round-the-flag-effect/.

Khosravi M. (2020), “Perceived Risk of COVID-19 Pandemic: The Role of Public Worry and Trust”, Electronic Journal of General Medicine, 17(4): em203.

Kriesi H. (2018), “The Implications of the Euro Crisis for Democracy”, Journal of European Public Policy, 25(1): 59–82.

Lewis-Beck M.S., and M. Paldam (2000), “Economic Voting: An Introduction”, Electoral Studies, 19(2–3): 113–121.

Lewis-Beck M.S., and M. Stegmaier (2000), “Economic Determinants of Electoral Outcomes”, Annual Review of Political Science, 3(1): 183–219.

Magalhães P.C. (2014), “Government Effectiveness and Support for Democracy”, European Journal of Political Research, 53(1): 77–97.

Mueller J.E. (1973), War, Presidents, and Public Opinion, New York: John Wiley & Sons.

Nadeau R., J.F. Daoust, and V. Arel-Bundock (2020), “The Market, the State and Satisfaction with Democracy”, West European Politics, 43(1): 250–59.

Naumann E., K. Möhring, M. Reifenscheid, A. Wenz, T. Rettig, R. Lehrer, U. Krieger, S. Juhl, S. Friedel, M. Fikel, C. Cornesse, and A.

Blom, (2020), “COVID‐19 Policies in Germany and Their Social, Political, and Psychological Consequences”, European Policy Analysis, 6(2): 191-202.

Norris P., ed. (1999), Critical Citizens: Global Support for Democratic Government, Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Olsen A.L., and F. Hjorth (2020), “Willingness to Distance in the COVID-19”, OSF Preprints, available at: https://osf.io/xpwg2/

Persson T., and G. Tabellini (2009), “Democratic Capital: The Nexus of Political and Economic Change”, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 1(2): 88–126.

Popkin S.L. (1994), The Reasoning Voter: Communication and Persuasion in Presidential Campaigns, 2nd ed., Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Putnam R.D. (1993), Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Putnam, R.D. (2000), Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community, New York: Simon and Schuster.

Roccato M., N. Cavazza, P. Colloca, and S. Russo (2020), “A Democratic Emergency After a Health Emergency? Exposure to COVID‐19, Perceived Economic Threat and Support for Anti‐Democratic Political Systems”, Social Science Quarterly, 101(6): 2193-2202.

Schraff D. (2020) “Political Trust During the Covid-19 Pandemic: Rally Around the Flag or Lockdown Effects?”, European Journal of Political Research, https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-6765.12425.

Segatti P. (2020), “La popolarità del governo Conte”, Il Mulino, https://www.rivistailmulino.it/news/newsitem/index/Item/News:NEWS_ITEM:5262.

Shao W., and F. Hao (2020), “Confidence in Political Leaders Can Slant Risk Perceptions of COVID-19 in a Highly Polarized Environment”, Social Science & Medicine, 1982(261): 113-235.

Sniderman, Paul M., Richard A. Brody, and Phillip E. Tetlock, (1993), Reasoning and choice: Explorations in political psychology, Cambridge University Press.

Sniderman P.M., and T. Piazza (1993), The Scar of Race, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Sibley C.G., L. Greaves, N. Satherley, M.S. Wilson, N. Overall, C. Lee, P. Milojev, J. Bulbulia, D. Osborne, T.L. Milfont, C.A. Houkamau, I.M. Duck, R. Vickers-Jones, and F. Barlow (2020), “Effects of the COVID-19 Pandemic and Nationwide Lockdown on Trust, Attitudes Towards Government, and Wellbeing”. https://psyarxiv.com/cx6qa (accessed 15 July 2020).

Toshkov D., K. Yesilkagit, and B. Carroll (2020), “Government Capacity, Societal Trust or Party Preferences? What Accounts for the Variety of National Policy Responses to the COVID-19 Pandemic in Europe?”, OSF Preprints. Epub ahead of print 29 April. DOI: 10.31219/osf.io/7chpu.

Van Deth J.W., M. Maraffi, K. Newton, and P.F. Whiteley (1999), Social Capital and European Democracy, London: Routledge.

Vezzoni C., R. Ladini, F. Molteni, G.M. Dotti Sani, F. Biolcati, A.M. Chiesi, M. Maraffi, S. Guglielmi, A. Pedrazzani, and P. Segatti (2020), “Investigating the Social, Economic and Political Consequences of Covid-19: A Rolling Cross-Section Approach”, Survey Research Methods, 14(2): 187-194.

Wright A.L., K. Sonin, J. Driscoll, and J. Wilson (2020), “Poverty and Economic Dislocation Reduce Compliance with COVID-19 Shelter-In-Place Protocols”, University of Chicago, Becker Friedman Institute for Economics Working Paper, 2020-40.

Woods J. (2011), “The 9/11 Effect: Toward a Social Science of the Terrorist Threat”, Social Science Journal, 48(1): 213–233.

Zarocostas J. (2020), “How to Fight an Infodemic”, The Lancet, 395(10225): 676.

Zettler I., C. Schild, L. Lilleholt, L. Kroencke, T. Utesch, M. Moshagen, R. Böhm, R., M. Back, and K. Geukes (2020), “The Role of Personality in COVID-19 Related Perceptions, Evaluations, and Behaviors: Findings across Five Samples, Nine Traits, and 17 criteria”, PsyArXiv, 23 March, available at: https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/pkm2a.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
Bookmark and Share


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.