Distrust and Stigmatization of NGOS and Volunteers at the Time of the European Migrant "Crisis". Conflict and implications on social solidarity


Abstract


This paper deals with the recent episodes of stigmatization of solidarity in the context of the European migrant "crisis". Securitarian measures frame as illegal not only migrants but also volunteers supporting them. Starting from the debate about "zero tolerance" policies, considered as a form of depoliticization of traditional politics, the research shows how NGOs and volunteers are becoming distrusted and conflictual, even if they long framed themselves as neutral and apolitical. An analysis of the recent emergency decrees and the decrease of trust in the Third sector, along with volunteers' criminalization, reveals a changed picture for Third sector organizations. The Ventimiglia case study is representative of this changed context. The 11th June 2015 the French-Italian border has been closed; since then, civil society has been involved in supportive and conflictual actions about the migrants' presence, while local politics tried to avoid political confrontation. In this situation, depoliticized politics has indirectly extended the target of its norms, stigmatizing not only migrants but also their supporters. We now deal with NGOs and volunteers conflictual and distrusted. Changes in the Third sector are helpful to consider the fragmentation and the politicization of solidarity.

DOI Code: 10.1285/i20356609v12i2p460

Keywords: Crime of solidarity; Depoliticization; Solidarity; Third sector; Zero tolerance

References


AIDA Asylum Information database (2017), Country report: Italy, 2017 Update, (https://www.asylumineurope.org/news/21-03-2018/aida-2017-update-italy)

Alteri L., Cirulli A., Raffini L. (2019), “L’innovazione Sociale Urbana tra Sperimentazione e Nuove Forme di Governance e Disimpegno del Welfare”, la Rivista delle Politiche Sociali, 1: 39-54

Amnesty International (2017), Human Rights Defenders under Threat – A Shrinking Space for Civil Society,

(https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/act30/6011/2017/en/)

Amnesty International (2019), Laws Designed to Silence: the Global Crackdown on Civil Society Organisations

(https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/act30/9647/2019/en/)

Anafé (2019), Persona Non Grata. Conséquences des Politiques Sécuritaires et Migratoires à la Frontière Franco-Italienne. Rapport D’observation 2017-2018, January 2019, (http://www.anafe.org/spip.php?article520)

Associazione Studi Giuridici sull’Immigrazione (2015), Le Riammissioni di Cittadini Stranieri a Ventimiglia. Profili di Illegittimità, Giugno 2015, (http://www.asgi.it/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/Documento-Ventimiglia.pdf)

Basara T., “The Saved and the Drowned: Governing Indifference in the Name of Security”, Security Dialogue, 46(3): 205-220

Blais M. (2012) [2007], La solidarietà. Storia di un’idea, Milano: Giuffré Editore

Burnham P. (2001), “New Labour and the Politics of Depoliticization”, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 3 (2): 127-149

Busso S., Gargiulo E. (2017), “Una “Società Armoniosa”? Il Posto del Conflitto nelle Pratiche e nel Discorso sul Terzo Settore”, in Ferraro S., Gardini, E. (a cura di), Le Metamorfosi del “Paesaggio Sociale”, Milano-Udine: Mimesis Edizioni

Chiaramonte X., Senaldi A. (2018), Violenza Politica. Una Ridefinizione del Concetto oltre la Depoliticizzazione, Milano: Ledizioni LediPublishing

Chouliaraki L. (2013), The Ironic Spectator. Solidarity in the Age of Post-humanitarianism, London: Polity Press

Chouliaraki L., Musarò P. (2017), “The Mediatized Border: Technologies and Affects of Migrant Reception in the Greek And Italian Borders”, Feminist Media Studies, 17(4): 535-549

Cobbe L. (2014), “Solidarietà in Movimento. Politica, Sociologia e Diritto tra Welfare e Globalizzazione”, Scienza & Politica, XXVI (51): 3-16

Dal Lago A. (1999), Non-Persone. L’esclusione dei Migranti in una Società Globale, Milano: Giangiacomo Feltrinelli Editore

Dal Lago A. (2000), La Produzione della Devianza: Teoria Sociale e Meccanismi di Controllo, Verona: Ombre corte edizioni

de Nardis F. (2017), “The Concept of De-Politicization and its Consequences”, PArtecipazione e COnflitto, 10 (2): 340-356

Donati P. (1996), Sociologia del Terzo Settore, Roma: La Nuova Italia Scientifica

Dupuy K., Ron J., Prakash A. (2016), “Hands Off My Regime! Governments’ Restriction on Foreign Aid to Non-Governmental Organization in Poor and Middle-Income Countries”, World Development, 84:299-311

Eikenberry A. M., Kluver J. D. (2004), “The Marketization of Non Profit Sector: Civil Society at Risk?”, Public Administration Review, 64 (2): 132-140

Eldeman Trust Barometer (2018), Global Report, (http://cms.edelman.com/sites/ default/files/2018-02/2018_Edelman_Trust_Barometer_Global_Report_FEB.pdf)

Eldeman Trust Barometer (2019), Global Report, (https://www.edelman.com/trust-barometer)

Eurispes, Rapporto Italia 2018, (https://eurispes.eu/?option=com_content&view= category&id=47&Itemid=222)

European Commission (2015), Communication from The Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and The Committee of the Regions. A European Agenda on Migration, Brussels, May 13, 2015, (https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/sites/homeaffairs/files/what-we-do/ policies/european-agenda-migration/background-information/docs /communication_on_the_european_agenda_on_migration_en.pdf)

Fassin D. (2012), Humanitarian Reason: A Moral History of the Present, Berkeley, CA: California University Press

Fekete L., Webber F., Edmond-Pettitt A. (2017), Humanitarism: The Unacceptable Face of Solidarity, Institute of Race Relation, (https://s3-eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/ wpmedia.outlandish.com/irr/2017/11/10092853/Humanitarianism_the_unacceptable_face_of_solidarity.pdf)

Frontex - European Border and Coast Guard Agency, Risk Analysis for 2017, (https://frontex.europa.eu/assets/Publications/Risk_Analysis/Annual_Risk_Analysis_2017.pdf)

Gargiulo E. (2018), “Una Filosofia della Sicurezza e dell’ordine. Il Governo dell’immigrazione secondo Minniti”, Meridiana, 91: 151 – 173

Georgiou M., Zabarowski R. (2016), Media Coverage of the “Refugee Crisis”: A Cross-European Perspective, Council of Europe Report DG1(2017)03

Giddens A. (1994) [1990], Le Conseguenze della Modernità: Fiducia e Rischio, Sicurezza e Pericolo, Bologna: il Mulino

Giliberti L. (2017), “La Criminalizzazione della Solidarietà ai Migranti in Val Roja: Note dal Campo”, Mondi Migranti – Rivista di Studi e Ricerche sulle Migrazioni Internazionali, 3: 161 - 181

Goffman E. (2003) [1963], Stigma l'identità negata, Verona: Ombre corte.

Gramellini, M. (2018), Cappuccetto Rosso. Revised july 14, 2019, Retrieved december 17, 2018 (https://www.corriere.it/caffe-gramellini/18_novembre_22/cappuccetto-rosso-cd85367c-edd1-11e8-be2f-fc429bf04a05.shtml)

Guidi R., Andretta M. (2015), “Between Resistance and Resilience. How Do Italian Solidarity Purchase Groups Change in Times of Crisis and Austerity?”, PArtecipazione e COnflitto, 8 (2): 443-477

Harvey D. (1989), “From Managerialism to Entrepreneurialism: The Transformation in Urban Governance in Late Capitalism”, Geografiska Annaler. Series B, Human Geography, 71 (1), The Roots of Geographical Change: 1973 to the Present, 3-17

Kousis M. (2017), “Alternative Forms of Resilience Confronting Hard Economic Times: A South European Perspective”, PArtecipazione e COnflitto, 10 (1): 119-135

Link B. G., Phelan J. C. (2001), “Conceptualizing Stigma”, Annual Review of Sociology, 27: 363-385

Little A., Vaughan-Williams N. (2017), “Stopping Boats, Saving Lives, Securing Subjects: Humanitarian Borders in Europe and Australia”, European Journal of International Relations, 23(3): 533-556

Lunaria (2017), Cronache di ordinario razzismo, Quarto Libro Bianco Sul Razzismo In Italia, Roma, https://www.lunaria.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/quarto_libro_bianco_razzismo_web.pdf

Maccanico Y., Hayes B., Kenny S., Barat F. (2018), The Shrinking Space for Solidarity with Migrants and Refugees. How the European Union and Member States Target and Criminalize Defenders of the Rights of People on the Move, Trasnational Institute, Amsterdam, (https://www.tni.org/en/publication/the-shrinking-space-for-solidarity-with-migrants-and-refugees)

Marcon G. (2002), Le Ambiguità degli Aiuti Umanitari. Indagine Critica sul Terzo Settore, Milano: Feltrinelli Editore

Marelli S. (2011), ONG: una Storia da Raccontare. Dal Volontariato alle Multinazionali della Solidarietà, Roma: Carocci editore

Mattoni A., Vogiatzoglou M. (2014), “Italy and Greece, Before and after the Crisis: between Mobilization and Resistance against Precarity”, Quaderni, 84: 57-71

Mazzara F. (2019), Reframing migration. Lampedusa, Border Spectacle and Aestetics of Subversion, London: Peter Lang

Médecins Sans Frontières (2018a), Harmful Borders. An Analysis of the Daily Struggle of Migrants as They Attempt to Leave Ventimiglia for Northern Europe, February 2018, (https://www.msf.fr/sites/default/files/harmful_borders_190218.pdf)

Médecins Sans Frontières (2018b), Informal Settlements. Social Marginality, Obstacles to Healthcare and Basic Needs for Migrants, Asylum Seekers and Refugees, February 2018, (https://www.msf.fr/sites/default/files/out_of_sight_130218.pdf)

Milazzo G. (a cura di) (2018), Notizie di Chiusura. Sesto Rapporto Carta di Roma, Associazione Carta di Roma, (https://www.cartadiroma.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/Notizie-di-chiusura.pdf)

Ministero degli interni, Dipartimento per le Libertà civili e l'Immigrazione, Codice Di Condotta Per Le Ong Impegnate Nelle Operazioni Di Salvataggio Dei Migranti In Mare, 7 agosto 2017

Moro G. (2014), Contro Il Non Profit, Bari: Laterza

Musarò P., “Mare Nostrum: The Visual Politics of a Military-Humanitarian Operation in The Mediterranean Sea”, Media, Culture & Society, 39(1): 11-28

Oxfam (2018), Nowhere but Out. The Failure of France and Italy to Help Refugees and other Migrants Stranded at the Border in Ventimiglia, Oxfam Briefing Paper, June 2018, (https://www.oxfamitalia.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/bp-nowhere-but-out-refugees-migrants-ventimiglia-150618-en_update.pdf)

Paci M. (2008), “Welfare, Solidarietà Sociale e Coesione della Società Nazionale”, Stato e mercato, 1: 3-29

Pisanello C. (2017), In Nome del Decoro. Dispositivi Estetici e

Politiche Securitarie, Verona: Ombre Corte

Polman L. (2009), L᾽Industria della Solidarietà. Aiuti Umanitari nelle Zone di Guerra, Milano: Bruno Mondadori

Salvini A. (2012), Volontariato come Interazione. Come Cambia la Solidarietà Organizzata in Italia, Pisa: Pisa University Press

UN Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial, Summary or Arbitrary

Executions (2018), Saving Lives Is Not a Crime,

(https://www.ohchr.org/en/issues/executions/pages/srexecutionsindex.aspx)

Wacquant L. (2009) [1999], Prisons of Poverty, Minneapolis, London: University of Minnesota Press

Walters W. (2011), “Foucault and Frontiers: Notes on the Birth of the Humanitarian Border”, in Bröckling U., Krasmann S., Lemke T., Governmentality: Current Issue and Future Challenges, New York: Routledge, 138-164

Yin R. (1994), Case Study Research Design and Methods (2nd ed., Applied social research methods series 5), Sage


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
Bookmark and Share


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.