Beyond Essentialist and Functionalist Analyses of the "Politicisation of Religion": The Evolution of Religious Parties in Political Catholicism and Political Islam


Abstract


The debate about “politics and religion” has already rejected essentialist claims of fundamental differences in the impact of religion on politics in different cultures. This article will argue that political Islam in Turkey and political Catholicism in Italy and Germany adopted remarkably similar patterns of cross-class coalitions and policies for a “reconciliation of capitalism and democracy”. First, religious parties developed as mass integration parties which already encompassed cross-class coalitions. Second, in the aftermath of political and economic crises these parties transformed into catch-all parties with a pronounced neo-liberal agenda which was given a religious justification. Third, at the same time these parties continued to sponsor policies and organizations which cushioned and supplemented an uneven economic development. Fourth, the parties kept traditional family policies which helped attracting a significant female electorate. “Organized religion” provided religious parties with a potential electorate, ancillary organizations and ideological concepts; however, their role in this political evolution changed. The conclusion will discuss whether these findings can be generalized.

DOI Code: 10.1285/i20356609v7i1p111

Keywords: Christian democracy; “Muslim democracy”; AKP; politics and religion; party politics

References


Altinordu A (2010), “The politicization of religion: Political Catholicism and Political Islam in comparative perspective” Politics and Society 38 (4), 517-551, doi: 10.1177/0032329210381238

Atasoy Y. (2009), Islam’s marriage with neo-liberalism; state transformation in Turkey. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

Cinar M. and B. Duran (2008), “Evolution of contemporary political Islam”. In: Secular and Islamic politics in Turkey. The making of the Justice and

Development Party, Ü. Cizre (Ed), London and New York: Routledge.

Conway M. (2001), “Catholic politics or Christian Democracy? The evolution of inter-war political Catholicism”. Christdemokratie in Europa im 20. Jahrhundert, Gehler, M., Kaiser, W and H. Wohnout (Eds.), Wien: Böhlau.

Conway M. (2003), “The age of Christian democracy”, in European Christian Democracy. Historical legacies and comparative perspectives, T. Kselman and J. A.Buttigieg (Eds.), Notre Dame: University Press.

DiMaio T. (2001), “Zwischen Krise des liberalen Staates, Faschismus und demokratischer Perspektive. Die Partito Populare Italiano 1919-1926“, in Christdemokratie in Europa im 20. Jahrhundert, Gehler, M., Kaiser, W. and H. Wohnout (Eds.), Wien: Böhlau.

Driessen M. (2003), Religious democracy and civilisational politics: comparing political Islam and political Catholicism. Center for International and Regional Studies Georgetown University Qatar. Occasional Paper No.12.

Duran B. and E. Yildirim (2005), “Islamism, trade unionism and civil society: The case of Hak-Is Labout confederation in Turkey“, Middle Eastern Studies, 41(2), 227-247, doi:10.1080/00263200500035199

Duran B. (2008), “The Justice and Development party's new politics”, in Secular and Islamic politics in Turkey. The making of the Justice and Development Party, Ümit Cizre (Ed.), London and New York: Routledge.

Duyulmus C. U. (2011), “Social security reform in Turkey”, in The EU and the domestic politics of welfare state reforms, Paolo Graziano et. al. (Eds), London: Palgrave Mamillan.

Esping-Anderson G. (1989), Three worlds of welfare capitalism, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Gerhards J. (2007), Cultural overstretch? Differences between the old and new member states of the EU and Turkey, London and New York: Routledge.

Ginsborg P. (2000),”The politics of the family in twentieth-century Europe”, Contemporary European History, 9 (3), 411-444.

Hale W. and E. Özbudun (2010), Islamism, democracy and liberalism in Turkey. The case of the AKP, London and New York: Routledge.

Huntington S. P. (1993), “The clash of civilizations?” Foreign Affairs, 72 (3), 22-49.

Inglehart R. and P. Norris (2000), “The Developmental Theory of the Gender Gap: Women's and Men's Voting Behavior in Global”, International Political Science Review, 21 (4), 441-463, doi:10.1177/0192512100214007

Kalyvas S. N. (1996), The rise of Christian Democracy in Europe, Ithaka and London: Cornell University Press.

Kalyvas S. N. (2003), “Unsecular Politics and Religious Mobilization”, in: European Christian Democracy. Historical legacies and comparative perspectives, T. Kselman and J. A.Buttigieg (eds.), Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press.

Kalyvas S. N. and K. van Kersbergen (2010), “Christian Democracy“, Annual Review of Political Science, 13, 183–209, doi: 10.1146/annurev.polisci.11.021406.172506

Kirchheimer O. (1965), „Der Wandel des westeuropäischen Parteiensystems“, PVS 6 (1), 20-41.

Lipset S. M. and S. Rokkan (1967), “Cleavage structures, party systems and voter alignments: An introduction”, in Party systems and voter alignments. Cross-national perspectives, Lipset, S.M. and S. Rokkan (Eds.), New York.

Masala C. (2001), “Die Democrazia Cristiana 1943-1963” in: Christdemokratie in Europa im 20. Jahrhundert, Gehler, M., Kaiser, W and H. Wohnout (Eds.), Wien, Köln, Weimar: Böhlau.

Misner P. (2003), “Christian democratic social policy” in: European Christian Democracy. Historical legacies and comparative perspectives, T. Kselman and J. A.Buttigieg (Eds.), Notre Dame: University Press.

Minkenberg P.M. (2007), “Democracy and religion. Theoretical and empirical observations on the relationship between Christianity, Islam and liberal democracy”, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 33 (6), 887-909, doi: 10.1080/13691830701432731

Morgan K.J. (2009), “The religious foundations of work-family policies in Western Europe” in: Religion, class coalitions, and welfare states, van Kersbergen, K. and P. Manow (Eds.), Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Nasr V. (2005), “The rise of ‘Muslim democracy’”, Journal of Democracy, 16 (2), 13-27.

Offe C. (1996), „Die Aufgabe von staatlichen Aufgaben. Thatcherismus und die populistische Kritik der Staatstätigkeit“ In: Staatsaufgaben, Grimm, D (Hg.), Frankfurt a.M: Suhrkamp, 317-352.

Önis Z. (2006), “The political economy of Turkey’s Justice and Development Party”, in The emergence of a new Turkey. Democracy and the AK Parti. Yavuz, H. (ed), London and New York: Routledge.

Önis Z. (2012), "The triumph of conservative globalism: The political economy of the AKP era", Turkish Studies 13(2), 135-152.

Özbudun E. (2000), Contemporary Turkish politics. Challenges to democratic consolidation, Boulder: Riemer.

Panebianco A. (1988), Political parties: organization and power, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Putnam R. (1993), Making democracy work, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Spicka M.E. (2007), Selling the economic miracle. Economic reconstruction and politics in West Germany, 1949-1957, New York: Berghahn.

Stepan A. (2001), “The world’s religious systems and democracy: crafting the ‘twin tolerations’”, in: Arguing comparative politics, Stepan, A., Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Tepe S. (2008), Beyond sacred and secular: politics of religion in Israel and Turkey, Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Toprak B. (2005), “Islam and democracy in Turkey”, Turkish Studies 6 (2), 167-186.

Trigilia C. (1998), Grandi partiti, piccole imprese, Bologna: Il Mulino.

Warner C. M. (2002), “Die katholische Kirche als politischer Akteur in Italien, Frankreich, und Deutschland“, Politische Vierteljahresschrift, Sonderheft, 33, 279-299.

Yavuz H (2009), Secularism and Muslim Democracy in Turkey, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.


Full Text: PDF

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.
Bookmark and Share


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribuzione - Non commerciale - Non opere derivate 3.0 Italia License.