Email this article “Don’t Mask the Truth”. Analyzing Anti-Mask Discourses Advanced by a ‘Trusted Expert’ and Activists Acting On- and Offline
Abstract
This paper investigates how health-related disinformation and conspiracy theories (CTs) about masks were constructed in the US in the roughly eighteen months since the COVID-19 outbreak was declared a pandemic. It examines the anti-mask discourses propagated by different actors using different media – renowned conservative radio talk-show host Rush Limbaugh, users who signed an online petition against school mask mandates, and anti-mask activists speaking at Board of education meetings – to create a more comprehensive view of the processes involved in the delegitimization of scientific, political, and mediatic authority, and the development and perpetuation of alternative truths. These discourses were analyzed principally by means of critical discourse analysis (CDA), and specifically the strategies of self- and other-presentation (Reisigl, Wodak, 2001; van Dijk 2000; Wodak 2011) and of (de)legitimation (Reyes 2011; van Leeuwen 2007). Findings suggest that these anti-mask actors leveraged extant conspiratorial beliefs and distrust of authorities to foster anti-mask sentiment, cast doubt on the interests served by key political and scientific figures, and question the veracity of the information imparted by left-leaning news networks, government institutions, and the scientific community, undermining trust in health recommendations.
References
Aaronson B., Glick S.N., Kirk C.J., et al. 2021, Assessment of Feasibility of Face Covering in School-Aged Children With Autism Spectrum Disorders and Attention- Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder, in “JAMA Netw Open” 4 [5]:e2110281.
Abbas A.H. 2021, Politicizing COVID-19 Vaccines in the Press: A Critical Discourse Analysis, in “Int J Semiot Law”, advance online publication.
Abramson A. 2017, President Trump's Allies Keep Talking About the 'Deep State.' What's That?, in “Time”. https://time.com/4692178/donald-trump-deep-state-breitbart- barack-obama/ (15.12.2021).
Aerts O., Dendooven E., Foubert K., et al. 2020, Surgical mask dermatitis caused by formaldehyde (releasers) during the COVID-19 pandemic, in “Contact Dermatitis” 83, pp. 172-173.
Brenan M. 2020, Americans’ Reported Use of Face Masks Surges in Past Week, in “Gallup”. https://news.gallup.com/poll/308678/americans-reported-face-masks- surges-past-week.aspx (12.09.2021).
Bruns A., Harrington S., Hurcombe E. 2021, Coronavirus Conspiracy Theories: Tracing Misinformation Trajectories from the Fringes to the Mainstream, in Lewis M., Govender E., Holland K. (eds.), Communicating COVID-19, Palgrave Macmillan, Cham.
Douglas K.M., and Sutton R.M. 2015, Climate change: Why the conspiracy theories are dangerous, in “Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists” 71 [2], pp. 98–106.
Douglas K.M., Uscinski J.E., Sutton R.M., et al. 2019, Understanding Conspiracy Theories, in “Political Psychology” 40, pp. 3-35.
Fairclough N. and Wodak R. 1997, Critical discourse analysis, in Van Dijk T.A. (ed.), Discourse as Social Interaction, SAGE, London, pp. 128-147.
Franks B., Bangerter A., and Bauer M.W. 2013, Conspiracy theories as quasi-religious mentality: An integrated account from cognitive science, social representations theory, and frame theory, in “Frontiers in Psychology” 4 [424], pp. 1-12.
Fuchs C. 2021, Communicating COVID-19, Emerald Publishing Limited, Bingley. Goldberg J., 2021, Massapequa school officials say they won't mandate masks for students this year, in “Fox 5 NY”. https://www.fox5ny.com/news/massapequa-school-
officials-say-they-wont-mandate-masks-for-students-this-year (08.09.2021).
Grimes D.R. 2020, Health disinformation & social media, in “Science & Society” 21, pp.
-4.
Habgood-Coote J. 2019. Stop talking about fake news!, in “Inquiry” 62 [9-10], pp. 1033-
Hamel L., Kearney A. and Kirzinger A. et al. 2020, The Role of Misinformation, and
Views on A Potential Coronavirus Vaccine, in “Kaiser Family Foundation”. https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-COVID-19/report/kff-health-tracking-poll- september-2020/ (08.09.2021).
Horowitz D. 2020. New study: Millennials think their risk from COVID-19 is exponentially more than the true threat, in “Conservative Review”. https://www.theblaze.com/conservative-review/horowitz-new-study-millennials- think-risk-COVID-19-exponentially-true-threat (08.09.2021).
Jamieson K.H., Albarracín D. 2020. The relation between media consumption and misinformation at the outset of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic in the US, in “Harvard Kennedy School (HKS) Misinformation Review” 1 [2], pp. 1-22.
Kearney M.D., Chiang, S.C., and Massey P.M. 2020, The Twitter origins and evolution of the COVID-19 “plandemic” conspiracy theory, in “Harvard Kennedy School (HKS) Misinformation Review” 1 [3], pp. 1-18.
Kahane L.H. 2021, Politicizing the Mask: Political, Economic and Demographic Factors Affecting Mask Wearing Behavior in the USA, in “Eastern Econ J” 47, pp. 163-183.
News 12 Staff 2021, Locust Valley School Board vows to fight state school mask mandate, in “News 12 Long Island”. https://longisland.news12.com/locust-valley-school- board-vows-to-fight-state-school-mask-mandate (08.09.2021).
Muley P. 2020, ‘Mask Mouth’-a Novel Threat to Oral Health in the COVID Era–Dr Pooja Muley, in “Dental Tribune South Asia”. https://in.dental-tribune.com/news/mask- mouth-a-novel-threat-to-oral-health-in-the-COVID-era/ (08.09.2021).
Oliver J.E., and Wood T.J. 2014, Medical conspiracy theories and health behaviors in the United States, in “JAMA Internal Medicine” 174 [5], pp. 817–818.
Romer D. and Jamieson K.H. 2020, Conspiracy theories as barriers to controlling the spread of COVID-19 in the U.S., in “Social Science and Medicine” 263, pp. 1-8.
Reyes A. 2011, Strategies of Legitimization in Political Discourse: From Words to Actions, in “Discourse & Society” 22 [6], pp. 781-807.
Rouan R. 2020, Fact check: No, email to Fauci doesn't contain origin of a 'coronavirus bioweapon', in “USA Today”. https://eu.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2021/06/03/fact-check-email-fauci- doesnt-contain-origin-coronavirus/7511931002/ (08.09.2021).
Schneier B., 2003, Beyond Fear, Springer, New York.
Thorne K., 2021, NYS Health Dept. issues universal mask mandate for schools, 2 LI
school districts reviewing mandate, in “ABC 7 NY”. https://abc7ny.com/masks-in- school-emergency-regulation-regulatiuon-new-york-state-department-of- health/10983301/ (08.09.2021).
van Leeuwen T., 2007, Legitimation in Discourse and Communication, in “Discourse & Communication” 1 [1], pp. 91-112.
van Dijk T.A. 1993, Principles of critical discourse analysis, in “Discourse and Society” 4 [2], pp. 249-283.
van Dijk T.A. 1998, Ideology: A Multidisciplinary Approach, SAGE, London.
van Dijk T.A. 2000, The Reality of Racism, in Zurstiege G. (ed.), Festschrift für die
Wirklichkeit, VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften, pp. 211-225.
van Dijk T.A. 2006, Ideology and discourse analysis, in “Journal of Political Ideologies”
[2], pp. 115-140.
van Leeuwen T. 1993, Genre and field in critical discourse analysis, in “Discourse and
Society” 6 [1], pp. 81-106.
van Leeuwen T. 2007, Legitimation in Discourse and Communication, “Discourse &
Communication” 1 [1], pp. 91-112.
Wodak R. 2011, The Discourse of Politics in Action, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke. Wong J. and Claypool E., 2021, Narratives, masks and COVID-19: A qualitative reflection, in “Qualitative Social Work” 20 [1-2], pp. 206-213.
Zimmerman A., 2020, The Precautionary Principle in Mask-Wearing, in “Voices in Bioethics”, http://www.voicesinbioethics.net/COVID19/2020/3/30/the-
precautionary-principle-in-mask-wearing-when-waiting-for-explicit-scientific-evidence-is-unwise-1 (08.09.2021).
Zollo F., Bessi A., Del Vicario M., et al. 2017, Debunking in a world of tribes, in “PLoSONE” 12 [7], e0181821.
Full Text: PDF
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
