Email this article “Good Morning, Vietnam!” The discursive construction of nationhood in the War Remnant Museum wall-texts
Abstract
When the tourism industry is operatively organized by governmental institutions, it seems that the destination is commodified in ways that are ideologically constructed so as to ‘educate’ tourists to perceive them as having a historically different identity. This seems to be what happens when visiting the War Remnant Museum (WRM) in Vietnam. The WRM is a war museum, in Ho Chi Min City, containing exhibits related to the Vietnam and Indochina wars in a series of themed rooms; they include graphic photography accompanied by wall-texts, in English, Vietnamese and Japanese, covering the effects of such chemicals as Agent Orange andother defoliant sprays, the use of napalm and phosphorus bombs and other war atrocities. Since, in some guidebookswritten for an international Western audience,we readthat the Cold War is dealt with by looking at the US with a benevolent eye, there seems to be some dissonance between what the Cold War is, how it is described in guidebooks and what is told about the WRM.
The purpose of this study is to analyse the discursive construction of Vietnamese identity through the descriptions of war in the wall-texts found in the WRM. More specifically, this study aims to investigate how the WRM frames Vietnamese identity construction and how this can be inscribed in the tourist experience. This corpus-based methodological approach (WordSmith Tools and WMatrix) is grounded in critical discourse analysis (Fairclough 1989, 1992, 2001, 2006, 2014). What seems to emerge from this investigation is that the Vietnamese war, as depicted by the WRM,isnot simply the other side of the coin. Reality is filtered through anideological lens of political interpretation usedby the Vietnamese which frames discursive processes and strategies that establish the social order and power relations in a useful way in the construction of a strong national identity to be reproduced in WRM wall-texts. Such an analysis can provide useful insights intomultifaceted aspects of the institutional discourse(s) related to the construction of a national identity and at the same time linked to the commodification of war.
References
Alneng V. 2002,What the Fuck is a Vietnam?’ Touristic Phantasms and the Popcolonization of (the) Vietnam (War),“Critique of Anthropology”,22(4), pp. 461–489.
Best G. 2013,Dark detours: Celebrity car crash deaths and trajectories of place, in L. White and E. Frew (eds.), Dark tourism and place identity: Managing and interpreting dark places, Routledge, London, pp. 202–216.
Brown L. 2016,Tourism and pilgrimage: Paying homage to literary heroes,“International Journal of Tourism Research”, 18(2), pp. 167-175.
Busby G. and Devereux H. 2015,Dark tourism in context: The diary of Anne Frank. “European Journal of Tourism, Hospitality and Recreation”, 6(1), pp. 27–38.
Casella E. C. and FennellyK. 2016,Ghosts of sorrow, sin and crime: Dark tourism and convict heritage in Van Diemen’s Land, Australia, “International Journal of Historical Archaeology”, 20(3), pp. 506–520.
Catenaccio P. 2017,The Discursive Construction of a ‘Dark Tourism” Destination. The Touristification of Ground Zero and the Commodification of Tragedy on the 9/11 Memorial and Museum Website, in Gotti, M., Maci S.M., Sala M. (eds),Ways of Seeing, Ways of Being. Representing the Voices of Tourism, Peter Lang, bern, pp. 269–293.
Cheal F. and Griffin T. 2013,Pilgrims and patriots: Australian tourist experiences at Gallipoli,“International Journal of Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research”, 7(3), pp. 227–241.
Chilton P. 2004,Analysing Political discourse. Theory and Practice, Routledge, London.
Coldwell W. 2013,Dark tourism: why murder sites and disaster zones are proving popular, inThe Guardian. 31 October 2013. Available at:
Dehoorne O. andJolliffe L. 2013,Dark tourism and place identity in French Guiana,in L. White and E. Frew (eds.), Dark tourism and place identity: Managing and interpreting dark places, Routledge, London, pp. 156–166.
Devenish D.C. 1990,Labelling in Museum Display. A Survey and Practical Guide,“Museum Management and Curatorship”, 9,pp. 63–72.
Dyers C. and Wankah, F. J. 2012,“Us” and “Them”: The Discursive Construction of “the Other” in Greenmarket Square, Cape Town,“Language and Intercultural Communication”,12(3), pp. 230–247.
Fairclough N. 1989,Language and Power,Longman, London.
Fairclough N. 1992,Discourse and Social Change,Polity Press, Cambridge.
Fairclough N. 2001,The Dialectics of Discourse,“Textus”, 14(2): pp. 3–10. [Online]. Available at: http://www.tilgher.it/textusart_fairclough.html.
Fairclough N. 2005,Governance, partnership and participation: cooperation and conflict (Unpublished paper given at the conference of the International Association for Dialogue Analysis, Bucharest 2005).
Fairclough N. 2006,Language and Globalization, Routledge, London.
Fairclough N. 2014,Critical Language Awareness, Routledge, London.
Fairclough N.,Mulderrig J.,Wodak R. 2011,Critical Discourse Analysis,in van Dijk, T. (ed.), Discourse Studies. A multidisciplinary Introduction, Sage, London, pp. 357–378.
Falk J.H.and Dierkin, L.D. 2012 (1992), Museum Experience Revisited, Left Coast Press Inc, Walnut Creek.
Fallon P. and Robinson P. 2017,‘Lest we forget’: A veteran and son share a ‘warfare tourism’ experience, “Journal of Heritage Tourism”, 12(1), pp. 21–35.
Feighery W. 2011,Discourse and the governance of diversity in England's official tourism texts,“Journal of Policy Research in Tourism, Leisure and Events”, 3(2), pp. 121–146.
Forsdick C. 2014,Travel, slavery, memory: Thanatourism in the French Atlantic,“Postcolonial Studies”, 17(3), pp. 251–265.
Gabrielatos C. and Marchi A. 2012,Keyness. Appropriate metrics and practical issues. Paper presented at CADS 2012, University of Bologna.
Gillen J. 2014,Tourism and Nation Building at the War Remnants Museum in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam, “Annals of the Association of American Geographers”, 104(6),pp. 1307–1321.
GouldM.R. 2014,Return to Alcatraz: Dark tourism and the representation of prison history,in B. Sion (ed.), Death tourism: Disaster sites as recreational landscape, Seagull, London, pp. 267–288.
Hohenhaus P. 2013,Commemorating and commodifying the Rwandan genocide: Memorial sites in a politically difficult context, in L. White / E. Frew (eds.), Dark tourism and place identity: Managing and interpreting dark places, Routledge, London, pp. 142–155.
Hyde K. and Harman S. 2011,Motives for a secular pilgrimage to the Gallipoli battlefields,“Tourism Management”, 32(6), pp. 1343–1351.
Isaac R. K. and Çakmak E. 2014,Understanding visitor’s motivations at sites of death and disaster: The case of former transit camp Westerbork, The Netherlands,“Current Issues in Tourism”, 17(2), pp. 164–179.
Isaac R. and Çakmak E. 2016, Understanding the motivations and emotions of visitors at Tuol Sleng genocide prison museum (S-21) in Phnom Penh, Cambodia,“International Journal of Tourism Cities”, 2(3), pp. 232–247.
Jamal T. and Lelo L. 2011,Exploring the conceptual and analytical framing of dark tourism: From darkness to intentionality,in R. Sharpley and P. Stone (eds.), Tourist experience: Contemporary perspectives. Routledge, London, pp. 29–42.
Kamber M., Karafotias T., Tsitoura T. 2016, Dark heritage tourism and the Sarajevo siege,“Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change”, 14(3), pp. 155–269.
Kang E.J. and Lee T.J. 2013,War and ideological conflict: Prisoner of war camps as a tourist experience in South Korea, in L. White / E. Frew (eds.), Dark tourism and place identity: Managing and interpreting dark places, Routledge, London, pp. 236–247.
Kennicott P. 2014,The 9/11 Memorial Museum doesn’t Just Display Artifacts, It Ritualizes Grief on a Loop. Inside the National September 11 Memorial Museum, inWashington Post, June 7, 2014. Available at:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/entertainment/museums/the-911-memorial-museum-doesnt-just-display-artifacts-it-ritualizes-grief-on-a-loop/2014/06/05/66bd88e8-ea8b-11e3-9f5c-9075d5508f0a_story.html?utm_term=. ced6dd343b72
Kokkranikal J., Yang, Y. S., Powell, R., Booth, E. 2016,Motivations in battlefield tourism: The case of ‘1916 Easter Rising Rebellion’, Dublin,in V. Katsoni / A. Stratigea (eds.), Tourism and culture in the age of innovation, Springer, Heidelberg, pp. 321–330.
Koleth M. 2014,Hope in the dark: Geographies of volunteer and dark tourism in Cambodia,“Cultural Geographies”, 21(4), pp. 681–694.
Lelo L. and Jamal T. 2013,African Americans at sites of darkness: Roots-making, diasporic identities and place making, in L. White and E. Frew (eds.), Dark tourism and place identity: Managing and interpreting dark places, Routledge, London, pp. 28-45.
Lennon J.J. and Foley M. 2000,Dark Tourism: The Attraction of Death and Disaster,Continuum, London.
Levey C. L. 2014,The Navy Mechanics School (ESMA) and the politics of trauma tourism in Argentina, in B. Sion (ed.), Death tourism: Disaster sites as recreational landscape, Seagull, London, pp.205–225.
Light D. 2017,Progress in dark tourism and thanatourism research: An uneasyrelationship with heritage tourism,“Tourism Management”,61,pp. 275–301.
Louw B. 1993,Irony in the text or insincerity in the writer?,in M. Baker et al. (eds.) Text andTechnology, Benjamins, Amsterdam, pp. 157-176.
MacCarthy M. 2016,Consuming symbolism: Marketing D-Day and Normandy,“Journal of Heritage Tourism” (published online).
Maci S.M. 2015,‘For Your Eyes Only’: How Museum Walltexts Communicate East and West. The Case of the Peggy Guggenheim Foundation,“Languages Cultures Mediation”, 2(1),pp. 135–155.
Magee R. and Gilmore A. 2015,Heritage site management: From dark tourism to transformative service experience?,“The Service Industries Journal”, 35(15–16), pp. 898–917.
Margarito M.G. 2005,En accompagnement d’images... d’autres images parfois (notes sur des apartés de la BD),“Etudes de Linguistique Appliquée”, 138,pp. 243–255.
Margarito M.G. 2006,How to be evocative and inviting with expographic textes. Culture and Communication,Acts of the 19th Congress of Applied Linguistics,Université d’Avignon, Lab Culture and Communication,Avignon, pp. 130–133.
Montessoro F. 2000, Vietnam, Un secolo di storia, FrancoAngeli,Milano.
Montessoro F. 2004,Le guerre del Vietnam, Giunti, Firenze.
McManus P.M. 1989, “Oh, Yes, They Do”: How Museum Visitors Read Labels and Interact with Exhibit Text, “Curator”,32(3),pp. 174–189.
Nawijn J., Isaac R. K., van Liempt, A., Gridnevskiy, K. 2016,Emotion clusters for concentration camp memorials,“Annals of Tourism Research”, 61, pp. 244–247.
Partington A. 1998,Patterns and meanings, Benjamins,Amsterdam and Philadelphia.
Potts T. J. 2012,‘Dark tourism’ and the ‘kitchification’ of 9/11,“Tourist Studies”, 12(3), pp. 232–249.
Ravelli L. 1996. Making Language Accessible: Successful Text Writing for Museum Visitors. Linguistics and Education 8, 367–387.
Ravelli L. 2007,Museum Texts: Communication Frameworks, Routledge, London.
Rayson P. 2009,Wmatrix: a web-based corpus processing environment, Computing Department, Lancaster University,http://ucrel.lancs.ac.uk/wmatrix/
Sather-Wagstaff J. 2011,Heritage that hurts: Tourists in the memoryscapes of September 11,Left Coast Press, Walnut Creek, CA.
Sinclair J. 1999,Concordance tasks,available at: http://www.twc.it/happen.html (last accessed: June 2003), The Tuscan Word Centre.
Scott M. 2012,WordSmith Tools version 6, Stroud, Lexical Analysis Software.
Stone P.R. 2005,Dark tourism consumption – a call for research,“e-Review of Tourism Research”, 3(5), pp. 109–117.
Stone P.R. 2012a,Dark tourism as ‘mortality capital: The case of Ground Zero and the significant other dead, in R. Sharpleyand P. R. Stone (eds.), Contemporary tourist experience: Concepts and consequences. Routledge, London,pp. 71–94.
Stone P.R. 2016,Enlightening the ‘dark’ in dark tourism,“Interpretation Journal”, 21(2), pp. 22–24.
Sturken M. 2007,Tourists of History, Memory, Memory, Kitsch, and Consumerism from Oklahoma City to Ground Zero, Duke University Press,US.
Tarlow P.E. 2005,Dark tourism: The appealing ‘dark’ side of tourism and more,in M. Novelli (ed.), Niche tourism: Contemporary issues, trends and cases, Elsevier, Amsterdam,pp. 47–58.
Tinson J. S.,Saren M. A. J., Roth B. E. 2015,Exploring the role of dark tourism in the creation of national identity of young Americans,“Journal of Marketing Management”, 31(7–8), pp. 856–880.
UrryJ. 1990, The tourist gaze: leisure and travel in contemporary societies, Sage Publications, London.
YankholmesA. and McKercher B. 2015,Understanding visitors to slavery heritage in Ghana,“Tourism Management”, 51(12), pp. 22–32.
Young Marylin B. 1991,Vietnam Wars 1945–1990,HarperCollins. Kindle Edition.
Wang Y. and MoraisD. 2014,An examination of tourists’ identity in tourist weblogs,“Information Technology & Tourism”, 14(3), pp. 239–260.
Widdowson H. G. 2000,Linguistics,Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Full Text: PDF
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
