Different in Economics, Coordinated in Politics. Russia and China in the MENA region in the XXI century
Abstract
The article reviews Russia and China’s engagement with the Middle East and North Africa since the 1990s and assesses the scale and depth of their cooperation and competition in the region. The article argues for the development of a de facto convergence between the two states, with Russia at the forefront of diplomatic and military initiatives, and China supporting the latter’s actions in bilateral and multilateral relations with MENA partners. The regional crisis unleashed by Arab Uprisings have boosted such a cooperation between Moscow and Beijing, both in respect to their regional partners and Western rivals. And yet, they have also highlighted the different relevance that the region deserves in their respective international relations. On the background of the existing literature, the analysis of official statistics as well as of historical precedents, the two countries are analysed and compared along the topics of economy and politics-diplomacy.
References
Abdel-Malek, A 2004, ‘China’s Message to the Arabs’, Al-Ahram Weekly, 16 Sep-tember, viewed 10 April 2018, .
Adly, A 2018, ‘Beyond State and Market: Development Strategies in the Arab World’, in R Gillespie & F Volpi (eds), Routledge Handbook of Mediterranean Politics, Routledge, pp. 221–231.
Akl, Z 2019, ‘Russia and Post-Arab Spring Political Elites in Egypt, Libya and Syria’, in V Talbot & C Lovotti (eds), The role of Russia in the Middle East and North Africa Region. Strategy or Opportunism?, Euromesco Joint Policy Studies, pp. 54–69.
Akturk, S 2006, ‘Turkish-Russian Relations after the Cold War (1992-2002)’, Turkish Studies, vol. 7, no. 3, pp. 337–364. https://doi.org/10.1080/14683840600891034
Alami, M 2018, ‘Russia’s Local and Regional Approach to Syria’, Sada Journal, 31 July, viewed 2 September 2018, .
Alessandrini, S 2012, Foreign Direct Investments (FDI) to the Middle East and North Africa Region: Short- and Medium-Term Developments, Policy Brief, The German Marshall Fund of the United States, Istituto Paralleli.
Borshchevskaya, A 2017, The tactical side of Russia’s arms sale to the Middle East, The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, viewed 12 January 2019, .
Brown, K 2014, Mixed Signals: China in the Middle East, Policy Brief no. 190, December, viewed 3 December 2016, .
Carlsson, M, Oxenstierna, S & Weissmann, M 2015, China and Russia – A Study on Cooperation, Competition and Distrust, Report no. FOI-R-4087–SE, June, Swedish Defence Research Agency, .
Charap, S 2014, ‘Is Russia an Outside Power in the Gulf’, in T Dodge & E Hokayem (eds), Middle Eastern Security, the US Pivot to Asia and the Rise of ISIS, Routledge-IISS, pp. 185–204.
Cherif, Y 2019, ‘The Interests of Putin’s Russia in the MENA Region in Historical Perspective’, in V Talbot & C Lovotti (eds), The role of Russia in the Middle East and North Africa Region. Strategy or Opportunism?, Euromesco Joint Policy Studies, pp. 12–29.
Connolly, R & Sendstad, C 2017, Russia’s role as an arms exporter: The strategic and economic importance of arms exports for Russia, Research Paper, Chatham House Russia and Eurasia Program, viewed 4 March 2017, .
Dannreuther, R & March, L (eds) 2010, Russia and Islam. State, society and radicalism, Routledge, London; New York.
Dannreuther, R 2012, ‘Russia and the Middle East: a Cold War Paradigm?’, Europe-Asia Studies, vol. 64, no. 3, pp. 543–560. https://doi.org/10.1080/09668136.2012.661922
Dannreuther, R 2014, ‘Russia and the Middle East’, in H Carter & A Ehteshami (eds), The Middle East Relations with Asia and Russia, Routledge, pp. 22–40.
Davidson, C 2010, The Persian Gulf and Pacific Asia. From Indifference to Interdependence, Hurst&Co, London.
Degang, S & Zoubir, YH 2014, Building a New Silk Road: China and the Middle East in the 21st Century, World Affairs Press, Beijing.
Degang, S & Zoubir, YH 2015 ‘China’s Economic Diplomacy towards the Arab Countries: challenges ahead?’, Journal of Contemporary China, vol. 24, no. 95, pp. 903–921. https://doi.org/10.1080/10670564.2015.1013379
Dodge, T & Hokayem, E (eds) 2014, Middle Eastern Security, the US Pivot to Asia and the Rise of ISIS, Routledge-IISS, London.
Dusek, M & Kairouz, M 2017, ‘Is China pivoting towards the Middle East?’, World Economic Forum, 4 April, viewed 20 May 2017, .
Ezzat, D 2016, ‘China in the Middle East’, Al-Ahram, 20 January, viewed 29 January 2017, http://weekly.ahram.org.eg/News/15302.aspx.
Fawaz, GA 2012, Obama and the Middle East: the End of America’s Moment, Palgrave-MacMillan, New York.
Feng, C 2015, Embracing Interdependence: the Dynamics of China and the Middle East, Policy Briefing, Brookings Doha Center, viewed 19 March 2016, .
Findlay, R & O’ Rourke, K 2007, Power and Plenty. 2007. Trade, War and Economy in the Second Millenium, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Frappi, C 2018, ‘The Russo-Turkish Entente: A Tactical Embrace Along Strategic and Geopolitical Convergences’, in V Talbot (ed), Turkey: Towards a Eurasian Shift?, ISPI-Ledi Publishing, pp. 45–70.
Freedman, RO 2000, ‘Russian–Iranian Relations in the 1990s’, Middle East Review of International Affairs, vol. 4, no. 2.
Görgülü, A & Kahyaoğlu, DG (eds) 2019, The Remaking of the Euro-Mediterranean Vision. Challenging Eurocentrism with Local Perspectives in the Middle East and North Africa, Peter Lang, Bern.
Harb, M & Atallah, S 2015, Local Governments and Public Goods: Assessing Decentralization in the Arab World, Lebanese Center for Policy Studies, viewed 4 February 2016, .
Hartwell, CA 2019, ‘Russian Economic Policy in the MENA Region: A Means to Political Ends’, in V Talbot & C Lovotti (eds), The role of Russia in the Middle East and North Africa Region. Strategy or Opportunism?, Euromesco Joint Policy Studies, pp. 90–114.
Hegghammer, T 2006, ‘Global Jihadism After the Iraq War’, Middle East Journal, vol. 60, no. 1, pp. 12–32.
Hinnebusch, R 2003, The International Politics of the Middle East, Manchester University Press, Manchester.
Hokayem, E & Wesser, R 2014, ‘The Gulf States in an Era of American Retrench-ment’, in T Dodge & E Hokayem (eds), Middle Eastern Security, Routledge-IISS, pp. 135–164.
International Monetary Fund (IMF) 2018, Direction of Trade Statistics, viewed 12 March 2019, UK Data Service, .
Kalinovsky, A & Radchenko, S (eds) 2011, The End of the Cold War and the Third World. New Perspectives in Regional Conflicts, Routledge, London.
Kazemi, VA & Chen, X 2014, ‘China and the Middle East: More than Oil’, The European Financial Review, February-March, viewed 12 September 2016, .
Kozhanov, N 2018, Russian policy across the Middle East: Motivations and methods, Re-search Paper, Chatham House, February, viewed 3 March 2018, .
Kreutz, A 2007, Russia in the Middle East. Friend or Foe, Praeger, Westport CT; London.
Lavrov, S 2016, ‘Russia’s Foreign Policy: Historical Background’, Russia in Global Affairs, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation, 3 March, viewed 2 April 2016, .
Lovotti, C & Tafuro Ambrosetti, E 2019, ‘How does the European Union Perceive Russia’s role in the MENA Region?’, in V Talbot & C Lovotti (eds), The role of Russia in the Middle East and North Africa Region. Strategy or Opportunism?, Euromesco Joint Policy Studies, pp. 70–89.
Mammadov, R 2018, ‘Russia in the Middle East: Energy forever?’ Jamestown Foundation on-line brief, 8 March, viewed 10 March 2018, .
Milosevich, M 2019, ‘The 2010s: “Grand Strategy” or Tactical Opportunism’, in V Talbot & C Lovotti (eds), The role of Russia in the Middle East and North Africa Region. Strategy or Opportunism?, Euromesco Joint Policy Studies, pp. 30–53.
Mustapha, R 2010, Economic integration in the Mashreq, World Bank, viewed 11 De-cember 2011, .
Nakhle, C 2018, ‘Russia’s energy diplomacy in the Middle East’, in N Popescu & S Secrieru (eds), Russia’s return to the Middle East: Building sandcastles?, EU Institute for Security Studies, pp. 29–35.
Neill, A 2014, ‘China in the Middle East’, in T Dodge & E Hokayem (eds), Middle Eastern Security, the US Pivot to Asia and the Rise of ISIS, Routledge-IISS, pp. 205–224.
OECD 2010, Chinese Foreign Direct Investment Stock in the MENA, Paris.
Onnis, B 2011, La Cina nelle Relazioni internazionali. Dalle guerre dell’oppio ad oggi, Carocci, Roma.
Owen, R & Pamuk, S 1998, A History of Middle East Economy in the Twentieth Century, I.B. Tauris, London.
Pang, G 1997, ‘China’s Success in the Middle East’, Middle East Quarterly, vol. 4, no. 4, pp. 35–40.
People’s Republic of China (PRC) 2016, ‘China’s Arab Policy Paper’, Xinhua.net, January, viewed 12 February 2016, .
Poti, L 2018, Russian policies Towards the MENA Region, MENARA Working Paper no. 9, Istituto Affari Internazionali, viewed 1 September 2018, .
Presidency of the Russian Federation 2016, Foreign Policy Concept of the Russian Federation, 30 November, viewed 3 January 2017, .
Primakov, Y 2009, Russia and the Arabs. Behind the Scenes in the Middle East from the Cold War to the Present, Basic Books, New York.
Romagnoli, A & Mengoni, L 2014, The Economic Development Process in the Middle East and North Africa, Routledge, London.
Russian International Affairs Council (RIAC) 2016a, New Stage of Russia-Turkey Economic Relations, Report no. 28, viewed 20 April 2017, .
Russian International Affairs Council (RIAC) 2016b, The Institute for Iran-Eurasian Studies, Russia-Iran Partnership: an Overview and Prospects for the Future, Report no. 29, viewed 20 April 2017, .
Russian International Affairs Council (RIAC) 2017, Proposals on Building a Regional Security System in West Asia and North Africa, Report no. 38, viewed 20 April 2017, .
Russian International Affairs Council (RIAC) & Fudan University 2018, Russian-Chinese Dialogue: the 2018 Model, Report no. 39, viewed 29 August 2018, .
Samarani, G 2017, La Cina contemporanea. Dalla fine dell’impero ad oggi, Einaudi, Torino.
Santini, RH 2017, ‘A New Regional Cold War in the Middle East and North Africa: Regional Security Complex Theory Revisited’, The International Spectator, vol. 52, no. 4, pp. 93–111. https://doi.org/10.1080/03932729.2017.1371487
Scobell, AN 2016, China in the Middle East. The Wary Dragon, Rand Corporation, Santa Monica Calif, viewed 10 June 2016, .
Shichor, Y 1979, The Middle East in China’s Foreign Policy, 1949-1977, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Simsek, N, Simsek, HA & Zhanaltay, Z 2017, ‘Analysis of bilateral relations be-tween Turkey and Russian Federation’, Bilig, no. 83, pp. 1-26.
Sputnik International 2016, The Country We Used to Know is no More: Possible Scenarios for Post-War Syria, 19 August, viewed 8 September 2016, .
Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) 2017a, China export to MENA countries, Trend Indicators Value (TIVs), 1992-2015, viewed 10 De-cember 2017, .
Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) 2017b, Russia to Middle East Countries. Transfers of major conventional weapons: sorted by supplier. Deals with deliveries or orders made for year range 1950 to 2015, viewed 10 December 2017, .
Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) 2018, Military Expenditure Data, 1988–2015, viewed 12 December, .
Sotloff, S 2012, ‘China’s Libya Problem’, The Diplomat, 14 March, viewed 3 September 2017, .
Talbot, V & Lovotti, C (eds) 2019, The role of Russia in the Middle East and North Africa Region. Strategy or Opportunism?, Euromesco Joint Policy Studies, Barcelona.
Teti, A 2015, ‘Democracy Without Social Justice: Marginalization of Social and Economic Rights in EU Democracy Assistance Policy after the Arab Uprisings’, Middle East Critique, vol. 24, no. 1, pp. 9–25. https://doi.org/10.1080/19436149.2014.1000076
Teti, A & Abbott, PA 2017, ‘Perceptions of EU Foreign Policy in the MENA Re-gion’ Open Democracy, 12 August, viewed 14 August 2017, .
Trentin, M 2014, ‘Boom e Crisi. Lo sviluppo economico dei MENA negli anni Duemila a confronto con i lunghi anni Settanta’, in B Airò & M Zaccaria (eds), I confini della cittadinanza nel nuovo Medio Oriente, Asia Major, pp. 71–86.
Trentin, M 2018, ‘Power and Integration. An Historical Overview on Euro- Medi-terranean Relations’, Marmara University Journal of Political Science, vol. 6, pp. 1–18. https://doi.org/10.14782/ipsus.421020
UnctadStat, 2017, Container Port Throughput, Annual, 2008-2014, viewed 19 January 2017, .
Vasiliev, A 2018, Russia’d Middle East Policy. From Lenin to Putin, Routledge, Abing-don, Oxon.
World Bank (WB) 2010, Economic integration in the Gulf Cooperation Council, viewed 11 December 2011, .
World Bank (WB) 2018, ‘Merchandise imports and exports of all MENA, 1960-2015’, World Development Indicators, viewed 4 November 2016, .
Zambelis, C & Gentry, B 2008, ‘China through Arab Eyes: American Influence in the Middle East’, Parameters, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 60–72.
Zvjagel’skaja, I 2016, ‘Russia, the New Protagonist in the Middle East’, in A Ferrari (ed), Putin’s Russia: Really Back? Ledizioni, ISPI.
Full Text: pdf
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.